Transcript Slide 1

Human Engineering
Cloning, Stem-Cell Research,
and In Vitro Fertilization
Genetic Engineering
Manipulation of genetic material
in an attempt to modify the
structure of an organism or aid in
the transmission of genetic
information
 The substance of which
genes are a part is DNA
(deoxyribonucleic acid),
a long chainlike
molecule.
 DNA is the chemical
record in which
hereditary
information is encoded
 Human genes become defective
by mutation and by chromosome
aberration
 The term eugenics means “sell
born through the judicious
matching of superior genes”
• Negative (altering genetic
endowment by removing or
correcting harmful genes)
• Positive (creating new beings).
Genetic Engineering
The motivation behind most
human genetic engineering
research certainly is
commendable – not mad
scientists
Three Types of Genetic Research
1.Making minor changes in existing
structure – one of two ways:
a.By splicing in new genetic
material
b.By altering the material already
present
Goal: improving an organism, or
prevention or cure of disease
Few oppose such genetic engineering
Three Types of Genetic Research
2.Creating new life forms
a.Mixing genes to from any two
organism to produce an entirely
new creature
b.The result is a hybrid plasmid
bearing some characteristics of
both original organisms
Recent benefits: human insulin,
superwheat, organisms that eat oil
Dangers
Do Exist
 Production of diseasecausing bacterium
 Development of creatures
that can reproduce
 Disruption of the ecology
 New diseases in humans
and plants
Three Types of Genetic Research
3.Procreation
a.This field embraces artificial
reproduction
b.This includes such practices as:
a.Artificial insemination, (AIH, AID)
b.Artificial sexual selection
c.Surrogate parenting
d.In vitro fertilization
e.Embryo transfer
The Bible and
Genetic Engineering
Bible is a of complete and perfect
source of moral and spiritual
information (2 Tim. 3:16-17; 2 Pt. 1:3)
Difficult to discover how Bible is to
be applied in complex problems of
modern society
Must search for the principles that
are applicable
Biblical Ethics and
Reproduction Technology
Reproductive technologies techniques that deal with male and
female infertility through artificial
reproduction
Two distinctive areas in which
biblical ethics are relevant to human
reproduction technologies: before
conception and at conception
Human Reproduction Technologies
Before Conception
Genetic counseling is a medical
speciality that uses the latest
information on birth defects and
inherited diseases to help people as
they strive to plan their families,
protect their health, and protect the
health of their children.
♦ Counselors have training in genetics
♦ Their goal is to translate up-to-date
genetic knowledge into practical,
useful information
♦ To date, scientists have isolated over
3,000 genetic defects among
humans
♦ Awareness of these defects may aid
those at risk in their decision making
Those at risk:
 People who have a family
history of inherited disease(s)
 Women who have experienced
two or more miscarriages
 Workers whose jobs expose
them to a potentially harmful
environment
 Those married to first cousins or
other blood relatives
 Etc.
 Two choices:
• Terminate a pregnancy if the fetus
is found to be defective – this is
both unethical and unscriptural
• To have or nor have children –
either choice is ethical and
scriptural
 Birth control is permissible
scripturally – and wise, if there
is evidence that a child might
be diseased or disabled
Human Reproduction Technologies
At Conception
 Reproductive technologies at
conception usually include:
 Cloning
 Artificial insemination
 In vitro fertilization.
History of Cloning
• 1952 – Briggs and King cloned
tadpoles
• 1996 – The first mammal cloned
from adult cells was Dolly, the
sheep
History of Cloning
July 1998
cloned calves
1998
Cloned
mouse
History of Cloning
December 2001
Five cloned female
piglets, named Noel,
Angel, Star, Joy and
Mary
December 2001
The world's first
cloned kitten,
named Cece
History of Cloning
2003
Cloned
mule
2004
Bull serialcloned
Reproductive Cloning
 The word “clone” derives from the
Greek term klon, meaning a “sprout”
or “twig.”
 Cloning is an asexual process of
reproduction that results in an exact
genetic duplicate of the original
 Thus, it refers to a method of
reproduction apart from the parental,
sexual-mating process that is
characteristic of most organisms.
Reproductive Cloning
 Suggested benefits:
 Children for unmarried
 Parents select characteristics
 Statistical studies
 Harvest “spare parts”
 Duplicate likeness of self
!
Cloning Humans Is Morally Wrong!
“Producing people in ‘herds’ in order
to harvest spare parts, for use in
laboratory statistical studies like so
many guinea pigs, or merely to
satisfy personal egos in a vain
attempt to guarantee physical
immortality is abhorrent”
(Bert Thompson, Ft. Wroth Lectures,
2000)
Cloning Humans Is Morally Wrong!
• Cloning opposes God’s design for
bringing children into the world in a
family unit [includes both a husband
and wife in the procreation act]
• Marriage is to proceed the bearing
of children (1 Tim. 5:14; Gen. 4:1)
• Children are to be reared within the
circle of the family unit (Gen. 1:28;
2:24; cf. Eph. 6:1-4)
Cloning Humans Is Morally Wrong!
 Dolly’s
experimenters used 277
cloned embryos to produce one
sheep, meaning 276 failed
 In
attempt to clone one human,
hundreds of embryos will be
produced and die in the process –
embryos are living human beings
(Gen. 9:6; Rom. 13:9)
Therapeutic Cloning
• “Therapeutic” Cloning creates an
embryo for destruction
• Therapeutic cloning involves cloning
human embryo cells to get stem
cells from them (killing the embryo)
• Stem cell - a cell that has the ability
to continuously divide and
differentiate (develop) into various
other kinds of cells/tissues
Kinds of Stem Cells
Stem cell
type
Totipotent
Pluripotent
Multipotent
Description
Each cell can
develop into a new
individual
Examples
Cells from early
(1-3 days)
embryos
Some cells of
Cells can form any
blastocyst (5 to
(over 200) cell types
14 days)
Cells differentiated,
Fetal tissue,
but can form a
cord blood, and
number of other
adult stem cells
tissues
Stages of Embryogenesis
Day 1
Fertilized egg
Day 2
2-cell embryo
Day 11-14
Tissue Differentiation
Day 3-4
Multi-cell embryo
Day 5-6
Blastocyst
Derivation and Use of Embryonic
Stem Cell Lines
Isolate inner cell mass
(destroys embryo)
Outer cells
(forms placenta)
Inner cells
(forms fetus)
Day 5-6
Blastocyst
Culture cells
“Special sauce”
(largely unknown)
Liver
Kidney
Heart muscle
Heart
repaired
Possible Uses of Stem
Cell Technology
•
•
•
•
Replaceable tissues/organs
Repair of defective cell types
Delivery of genetic therapies
Delivery chemotherapeutic agents
Embryonic Stem Cell
Engineering Is Morally Wrong
Adult stem cells (obtained from
adult tissues, cord blood, etc.) do
not pose any ethical controversies,
since they do not destroy complete
human beings
However, embryonic stem cells are
isolated by destroying human
embryos
Adult Stem Cells
 An
alternative source (does not
involve the destruction of human
embryos)
Adult Stem Cells
• Can come from a donor or individual
needing treatment
• Limited differentiation?
• Many clinical advantages over ESCs
–No tissue rejection
–Come from many places in the
body (Placenta, cord blood, bone
marrow, kidneys, hair follicles)
Adult Stem Cells
Currently used to treat over 70
diseases
Leukemia, breast cancer, liver
disease, cornea restoration, brain
tumors, arthritis, and heart disease
Adult Stem Cells
Heart Disease
C.J. Chiu, professor of cardiothoracic
surgery injected adult stem cells from
bone marrow into the hearts of rats.
These cells differentiated into new
heart muscle that made the right
connections to nearby cells so they
could all beat together.
Adult Stem Cells
Skin Disease
Adult stem cells can be transformed
into skin cells which can be used for
skin grafts.
Adult Stem Cells
Diabetes
A team led by University of Florida
permanently cured insulindependent diabetes in mice, with
adult stem cells.
Adult Stem Cells
“Given the abundance of umbilical
cord stem cells and the fact that
umbilical cord cells are already being
used for other disorders like childhood
leukemia, many researchers expect
that umbilical cord stem cells will start
being used to treat stroke victims
within the next few years.”
About Genetics, “Umbilical Cord Stem Cells: Hope for
Millions?” Feb 2001, (the annual meeting of the
American Association for the Advancement of Science)
Adult Stem Cells
‘Adult stem-cell research … has
already shown itself to be
extremely promising for treating
numerous degenerative diseases
such as heart disease, stroke,
Parkinson’s, Alzheimer’s, and
diabetes.
David Prentice (Ph.D. Genetics), National Review,
2001
Adult Stem Cells
“Presently, no one has succeeded
using ESCs for human therapeutic
or reproductive cloning…”
Daniel Criswell (Ph.D. Molecular Biology), “Stem
Cell research: Greasing the ‘Slippery Slope’ to
Godlessness”, Impact, February 2005
Adult Stem Cells
• Celebrity Parkinson's disease victims
such as Michael J. Fox and Michael
Kinsley regularly tout ESC research
as the best hope for a cure of their
disease
• Both have remained strangely silent
about the fact that researchers
treated Parkinson's with the patient's
own adult stem cells
Human Reproduction Technologies
At Conception
 Reproductive technologies at
conception usually include:
 Cloning
 Artificial insemination
 In vitro fertilization.
 Artificial insemination (AI) is a
means of assisting reproduction
 Process involves concentrated
sperm being injected into the
female reproductive system
artificially
 Most couples utilize artificial
insemination because the husband
either is infertile or subfertile
Sperm Sources
AIH designation given to artificial
insemination performed using only
the husband’s sperm
AID designation given to artificial
insemination performed using only
donor sperm
AIDH designation given to artificial
insemination performed using sperm
from both husband and donor
 When the sperm of the husband is
used (AIH) the conception of the
couples own child results – no
biblical principle is violated
 The use of donor sperm, donor
eggs, or surrogate mothers, stands
in stark contradiction to God’s plan
for the home
 The family unit is the avenue by
which children may be brought into
the world legitimately (Gen. 4:1)
 Parental responsibility begins at
conception and continues to a point
of independent maturity
 It is morally wrong for any Christian
to surrender his or her reproductive
powers to another person, thus
ignoring the divine responsibilities
connected therewith
Bert Thompson: serious implications
regarding the use of AI
• Women could bear children for
unmarried men
• Women could bear children for other
couples (surrogate motherhood)
• Women could bear children for
homosexual men
• Women who are lesbians could have
children without a male partner
Human Reproduction Technologies
At Conception
 Reproductive technologies at
conception usually include:
 Cloning
 Artificial insemination
 In vitro fertilization.
 In vitro (IVF) is the procedure
whereby the woman’s egg [removed
by laparoscopy] is fertilized with
sperm in a laboratory Petri dish –
the so-called “test tube” baby
 Multiple eggs are extracted and
fertilized, but only a few (appearing
to be the healthiest) are selected for
implantation – the remaining
embryos are destroyed
 Even though these embryos were
fertilized outside the womb in a
Petri dish, they are human
 The wholesale production and
subsequent slaughter of innocent
human embryos in search for the
“fittest” that is deemed good
enough to be given a chance at
survival, is immoral (Isa. 9:6)