Section 16 Followup
Download
Report
Transcript Section 16 Followup
Section 16 Reporting Changes Under
the Sarbanes-Oxley Act:
What You Need to Know
Ronald O. Mueller
Stanton P. Eigenbrodt
August 29, 2002
Ronald O. Mueller
A corporate partner in Gibson Dunn's Washington,
D.C. Office, Mr. Mueller has extensive experience in
the corporate securities area with an emphasis on
proxy and disclosure issues, corporate governance,
executive compensation and corporate
transactions. Mr. Mueller served as legal counsel to
SEC Commissioner Edward H. Fleischman from
1989 to 1991, during which time the SEC
comprehensively revised the section 16 reporting
rules. He is a member of the ABA's Committee on
Federal Regulation of Securities, and has written
numerous articles and spoken extensively on
executive compensation issues and the SEC’s
reporting and disclosure requirements.
Contact Information:
202-955-8671 – direct dial
[email protected]
2
Stanton P. Eigenbrodt
Mr. Eigenbrodt is of counsel in Gibson Dunn's
Dallas office, and a member of the firm's corporate
department and the firm's executive compensation
practice group. Mr. Eigenbrodt 's practice includes
an emphasis on executive compensation matters,
including the Section 16 reporting rules. Mr.
Eigenbrodt also has a broad-based corporate
practice, including mergers and acquisitions of
public and private companies; public and private
debt and equity offerings; and advice regarding
disclosure issues under the Securities Exchange
Act of 1934. Mr. Eigenbrodt is the co-author of
“Disclosure Requirements” and “Compliance
Procedure and Programs” in A Practical Guide to
Section 16:Reporting and Compliance (Goodman
3d ed. 1997).
Contact Information:
214-698-3174
[email protected]
3
Overview of Presentation
• New Rules effective August 29, 2002
• What has changed and what has not
• The new reporting regime: accelerated 2 day
reporting for most transactions
• Transition issues
• Responding to the new reporting rules
• Helpful reminders
4
OVERVIEW
• Section 403 of Sarbanes-Oxley amended
Section 16(a) to require each report on a
change of ownership:
– To be filed “before the end of the second business
day following the day on which the subject
transaction has been executed” unless the SEC
determines that 2-day reporting “is not feasible.”
– Indicate ownership by the filing person of company
securities at the date of filing, taking into account the
reported transactions.
5
OVERVIEW
• The Act also requires electronic filing of
Section 16(a) reports no later than July 30,
2003.
– At that time, the issuer will be required to make
the report available through its website.
• The Act did not repeal the SEC’s general
rulemaking authority to interpret and exempt
transactions from Section 16.
6
The New 2-Day Reporting Requirement
The SEC adopted rules to implement
2-day reporting on August 27, 2002.
• These rules implement the mandate of
Sarbanes-Oxley for 2-day reporting of certain
transactions while maintaining much of the
pre-existing reporting regime.
• The SEC also amended Form 4 (with
conforming amendments to Forms 3 and 5) to
accommodate 2-day reporting.
8
What Has Changed Under
The New Rules?
What has changed?
The SEC Adopted Two Fundamental Changes to
the Previous Reporting Rules
• Eliminate the availability of Form 5 for reportable
16b-3 transactions between the company and
the insider, instead requiring Form 4 reporting.
• Amend the rules so that any required Form 4
report must be filed within 2 business days.
10
What has changed?
• Eliminate the availability of Form 5 for
reportable 16b-3 transactions between the
company and the insider.
• Form 4 (2 business day) reporting of Rule
16b-3(d), (e) or (f) transactions.
– Option grants/restricted stock grants.
– Sales of stock to the company.
– “Discretionary transactions.”
Technical amendment to “small transaction” reporting rule
makes it unavailable for these types of transactions.
11
What has changed?
• Amend the rules so that any required Form 4
report must be filed within 2 business days.
• 2 business day reporting for transactions
historically reported on Form 4:
– Open market or private stock sales.
– Open market or private purchases.
– Option exercises.
• 2 business day reporting for reportable 16b-3
transactions between the company and insider.
12
What has changed?
• 2 business day reporting is triggered from the
date of the transaction:
“Form 4 must be filed before the end of the
second business day following the day on
which the subject transaction has been
executed.”
– Date of execution is likely the date the insider is
irrevocably committed to the transaction and
price and quantity are fixed.
13
What has changed?
• SEC rules provide modified 2 business day
reporting for two categories of transactions.
– Rule 10b5-1 transactions (including limit orders).
– “Discretionary transactions” under plans.
IF the insider does not select the date of trade
execution.
• These transactions are deemed executed on
(so the 2 days runs from) the earlier of:
– the date the insider is notified of the transaction,
or
– the third business day after execution (T+3).
14
What has changed?
A “discretionary transaction” is a participant-directed
movement of a portion of his or her account balance
into or out of a company stock fund under a deferred
compensation plan. Discretionary transactions may
occur in a tax-qualified plan, such as a 401(k) plan, or
in a non-tax qualified plan, such as a SERP or a
directors’ fee deferral arrangement.
15
WHAT HAS NOT CHANGED UNDER THE
NEW RULES?
What has not changed?
• Exemptions from Section 16(b) liability have
not changed.
– Even reportable 16b-3 transactions remain
exempt from short-swing liability.
• Other reporting rules (and interpretations) are
largely unchanged, except for the timing of
Form 4 filings and the change to reporting
transactions under Rule 16b-3(d) through (f).
17
What has not changed?
• Many transactions not reportable at all under
a Rule 16a exemption:
– Purchases under 401(k) plans and employee
stock purchase plans.
– Allocations under ERISA profit-sharing plans and
employee stock ownership plans.
– Transfers pursuant to divorce decrees and
domestic relations orders.
– Changes in the form of ownership that do not
affect the insider’s pecuniary interest in the
shares.
18
What has not changed?
• Timing of Form 3 does not change.
• Form 5 survives, but with limited use:
– Gifts.
– Small acquisitions, meaning purchases
aggregating less than $10,000, but excluding Rule
16b-3 reportable transactions.
– Late reports.
19
The New Reporting Regime
Under the SEC rules, there are now 4 reporting
categories:
• T+2 reporting.
• Tmodified+2 reporting.
• Non-reportable transactions.
– Must reflect their effects under “holdings” column
on next Form 4.
• Form 5 transactions (EOY reporting).
20
Transition Issues
• New reporting effective for transactions
executed on or after August 29, 2002.
• Pre-August 29 transactions governed by old
rules:
– Transactions reportable on Form 4 under old rules
must be reported on or before Sept. 10, 2002.
– Transactions reportable on Form 5 under old rules
(including Rule 16b-3 transactions) must be
reported within 45 days of company’s FYE.
21
Responding to the New Reporting Rules
WHAT SHOULD YOU BE DOING NOW?
Responding to the New Reporting Rules
• Inform insiders of the new reporting deadlines.
– Gibson, Dunn has prepared a sample memorandum that is
available at
http://gibsondunn.com/practices/publications/detail/id/5
23/?pubItemId=6627
– Insiders should inform family members and others whose
holdings or transactions are attributed to them of the new
reporting deadlines.
• Designate at least two compliance officers.
– Consider adding compliance officers to the company’s
directors and officers’ insurance policy.
23
Responding to the New Reporting Rules
• Tighten preclearance procedures.
– Many companies have preclearance procedures
in place already, but if not they should now.
– Preclearance process should collect sufficient
information to prepare the Form 4.
– Need details of any 10b5-1(c) arrangements.
– Close coordination with the broker will be
necessary to promptly report execution of any
trade (whether executed in whole or in part).
24
Responding to the New Reporting Rules
• Coordinate with plan administrators on
discretionary transactions.
– Determine extent of insider’s control over timing of
transactions.
– How quickly can the administrator report
transactions.
– May need to suspend or restrict discretionary
transactions.
– Consider reporting insider’s instructions and
amending Form 4 once information is known.
25
Responding to the New Reporting Rules
• Obtain powers of attorney.
– May need broad authorization to allow compliance officers
to make inquiries of brokers, others to obtain necessary
information, in addition to filing authorization.
– Insider remains responsible for the filing and for disclosure
of the insider’s name in the proxy if forms are filed late.
• Catalog insiders’ holdings and other filing
information.
– Form is available at
http://gibsondunn.com/practices/publications/detail/id/5
23/?pubItemId=6627
• Consider a catch-up Form 4 filing.
26
Responding to the New Reporting Rules
• Consider the disclosure implications of
prompt reporting.
– Timing of option grants and public disclosure of
compensation decisions.
– Effect of frequent reporting of accruals under
compensation plans that do not qualify under the
exemption for “tax conditioned plans”.
– A shorter open trading window may help prevent
transaction information from dribbling into the
market over extended periods.
27
Helpful Reminders
Practical Tips for Filing and Reporting
Helpful Reminders
• Need not include SSN.
• “End of period holdings” column:
– Treated as a running total, taking into account
transactions reported on the form.
– Need not reflect the effect of transactions that
have not yet been reported.
– Effect of transactions that are not required to be
reported is based on last available statement.
– Inaccurate “end of period holdings” information is
not disclosable in the proxy under Item 405.
29
30
How to file your Forms 3, 4 and 5
• Via overnight courier (such as UPS) sent on
T+1.
• By faxing the report to a filing service or
GD&C in Washington, D.C. and having it
hand-delivered to the SEC.
– Advance planning will be crucial.
• Via EDGAR.
• Direct fax to the SEC is NOT available.
31
Tips and traps for EDGAR filing
• Use Form ID to request.
http://www.sec.gov/about/forms/formid.pdf
• Different CIK code for each insider.
• Check if insiders already have a CIK code
(search by last name).
http://www.sec.gov/edgar/searchedgar/cik.htm
If so, include that CIK on the Form ID.
• 5:30 p.m. EDT filing deadline.
32