Transcript METHODS AND GUIDELINES FOR A AFFORESTATION AND
METHODS AND GUIDELINES FOR ASSESSING AFFORESTATION AND REFORESTATION PROJECTS UNDER CDM
Indu K. Murthy Indian Institute of Science
Objectives
Explore the feasibility of afforestation and reforestation as potential CDM activity Adopt the guideline prepared by the Executive Board (EB) for energy and other Non-LULUCF sector activities – for forestry sector project activities Conduct a case study in Adilabad, Andhra Pradesh Develop a baseline Identify potential CDM activities
Guidelines
The CDM guideline outlines the following steps Description of project area and activities Baseline methodology Calculation of GHG/CO 2 emissions (and removal by sinks) Monitoring methodology Environmental impacts
Description of Project Area
Land use/forest/vegetation categories in the region The study region- district/forest division
Forest division
Mancherial Jannaram
Geographic area (ha) Dense forest Open forest Area (in ha) Scrub forest Blanks Total
225299 70550 29100 48614 29011 17806 24395 12922 8560 110669 (49%) 1121 60860 (86%)
Proposed CDM Activities
Activities Reforestation Secondary forest regeneration Teak regeneration Eucalyptus plantation Teak plantation Teak Afforestation Eucalyptus Mango (Agro-forestry)?
Will it satisfy the definition of forest and afforestation?
Purpose of Activity
Environmental – GHG relevant
Revegetate degraded forests and non-forest lands through reforestation and afforestation Sequester carbon in vegetation and soil
Environmental – Non-GHG related
Protection of watersheds Promotion of biodiversity
Socio-Economic
Enhance the biomass production and supply (FW, poles and timber to local communities Enhance production and access to NTFPs Create employment to local communities Build local institutions and strengthen their capacity
Activities
Technical Description of Project Activities
Technical Interventions
Mixed forest regeneration Protection Teak regeneration Eucalyptus Mango Removal of weeds, protection Land preparation, planting, protection… Land preparation, planting, protection…
Compatibility with Sustainable Development Goals
A&R programs are part of forest development in the district Increased participation of local communities JFM (CFM program) – ongoing Will adopt guidelines of this program Socio-economic development of forest dependent communities through increased Biomass supply NTFP supply
Baseline Development and Methodology
Types of Baseline
Project-Specific
Regional Multiproject
C stocks – Measured in the Baseline
GHGs to be Monitored
Within the project boundary the GHG to be monitored is; Carbon dioxide Dominant GHG in A&R activities A&R activities involve removal of carbon dioxide from atmosphere and fixing it in vegetation and soil
Land Categories and Features
Baseline status of land Degraded secondary forest Tenure/ Ownership Reserve forest – Forest Dept.
Degraded teak Cropland Reserve forest – Forest Dept.
Private - Farmers Dependence of community Subject to excessive extraction Marginal cropping / fallow
Carbon Pool AGB BGB Litter Soil
Methods
Method Adopted Quadrat/transect – Basal area Biomass equations Coefficients (Ratio of AGB/BGB) Literature Sampling Organic C estimation in the laboratory
C Stocks in Baseline and CDM Scenarios
Land category Secondary forest Teak Cropland Mango Eucalyptus Total C tC/ha BSL 39 31 22 Total C tC/ha CDM 58-59 61-90 36 32-51 Total C Increment tC/ha 19-20 (4,6) 30-59 (2,8) 13* (5) 9-28* (3)
* Options for cropland under BSL; ( )No. of years under protection
Costs & Potential CER Income from Natural Regeneration & Plantations
Natural regeneration costs – Behrunguda Plantation cost – AP FD CER units for forest carbon estimates are Rs. 500/MtC/yr ($10) Current prices lower Type of reforestation strategy Natural regeneration Eucalyptus plantation Establishment cost (Rs/ha) 500 24000 Projected C sequestered (MtC/ha/yr) 6.3 to 10.9
Gross annual income from CERs (Rs/ha/yr) 3000-5000 1.4 to 9.5
700-4750
Veg type Degraded teak BSL Degraded secondary forest BSL Cropland Reg secondary forest CDM Reg teak CDM Eucalyptus Mango
Transaction Cost For One Time Assessment Per Village
Cost estimate for vegetation C estimation (Rs.) Cost estimate for soil C estimation (Rs.) Total Cost (Rs.) Field 1200 Data entry Analysis 600 500 Field Lab 4200 850 50 1700 1450 550 300 500 600 700 100 100 500 500 250 250 100 3750 1800 1950 4200 4550 2800 2550
CDM Project Activities
Land category Extent (in ha) to be covered Phasing Type of afforestation/ reforestation Natural regeneration / planting Silvicultural practices Rotation period
Methods of Projecting C Stock Changes & Operational Life of the Project
Biomass growth models COMAP CO 2 FIX Actual measurements from similar projects implemented in the region Operational life of the project - Crediting period: 2002-2012 Rotation period varies for each project activity Secondary forest regeneration – no logging of timber (NTFP & FW extraction permitted) Teak: Long rotation – Over 30 years Eucalyptus: Short rotation ~ 10 years Mango: Long rotation – NTFP yield
Parameter
Monitoring Methodology & Institutional Arrangements
Methods Data to be monitored Frequency Institutional arrangement
Survival rate Quadrats – counting No. of seedlings Annual Participatory Biomass growth Soil carbon Quadrats – measure Field methods Soil sampling Lab estimation of soil C DBH & height Basal area Annual Soil organic carbon Once in 2 years Research Team Research team or Educational institution
Environmental & Socio-Economic Impacts – Issues, Parameters & Methods Indicator
Biodiversity Ground water
Parameter
No. of species/ha Depth of water NTFP species diversity - No. of plant spp.
- Products
Method Frequency
Quadrat Annual/Alt year Water height from surface Once a month Alternate years Annual Employment generation Person days/year Gender benefits NTFP availability Women days of employment/ Yr - Income - No. of HHs collecting HH survey Annual/Seasonal Annual Annual
Observations on Use of Guidelines Developed for Non-LULUCF Projects
Standard field ecological methods and forest mensuration techniques can easily be applied
Forest carbon pools
AGB BGB; ratio of AGB/BGB Litter (marginal); field measurements & literature Soil C
Non-GHG benefits
Biodiversity, ground water, NTFP availability can be measured Employment generated & income flows can be estimated
Participatory monitoring is feasible & desirable for some parameters Compatibility with sustainable development goals can easily be demonstrated
Transaction cost of estimating baseline is significant but not very high
Issues
Size and type of projects Project boundary – needs to be clearly defined to facilitate accurate accounting & verification C pools to be monitored & credited Soil pools large, high spatial variability, low annual increase Uncertainty in measurement of carbon stocks is not addressed Non-permanence Leakage – important For certain types of forestry projects although not for A&R projects
SBSTA & IPCC are developing Guidelines, Methods & Models to address these Issues
Acknowledgements
Ministry of Environment and CES Community Forestry International