Study of tt production at NLO
Download
Report
Transcript Study of tt production at NLO
Top at startup of LHC
Stan Bentvelsen (NIKHEF)
October 2nd, 2004
P2
Top commissioning studies
Top physics at LHC
Top one of ‘easiest’ bread and butter
1.
2.
Used as calibration tool
Rich in ‘precision and new
physics’
Cross section 830±100 pb
Top mass Mt, cross section σt
Resonances decaying into top
Commissioning for the top group:
Semi-leptonic top channel
detector tools involved:
Lepton reconstruction
Missing ET
Jets + calibration
B-tagging
Summarize studies already performed
Tasks to do before startup
What do we need as input from others?
What can/should we provide to collaboration?
Goals
Work done together with Marina Cobal
Stan Bentvelsen Commissioning Meeting Freiburg
P3
Initial commissioning studies
First evaluation of statistical uncertainty
on σtop and Mtop
Gold-plated channel : single lepton
P. Grenier
• pT (lep) > 20 GeV
• pTmiss > 20 GeV
• ≥ 4 jets with pT > 40 GeV
• ≥ 2 b-tagged jets
• | mjjb-<mjjb>|< 20 GeV
For initial run at LHC:
(L = 1033 cm-2s-1)
Pretty small uncertainties after very short
time of LHC running!
Period
evts
dMtop(stat)
/ -st
1 year
3x105
0.1 GeV
0.2 %
1 month
7x104
0.2 GeV
0.4%
1 week
2x103
0.4 GeV
2.5%
Stan Bentvelsen Commissioning Meeting Freiburg
P4
Systematic error on Mtop (TDR performance, 10 fb-1)
Initial performance : uncertainty on b-jet scale
expected to dominate
b-jet scale uncertainty
1%
5%
10%
Mtop
0.7 GeV
3.5 GeV
7 GeV
Cfr: 10% on q-jet scale 3 GeV on Mtop
Stan Bentvelsen Commissioning Meeting Freiburg
P5
Various scenarios currently under study
pp collisions
What variations in predictions of t-tbar – which generator to use?
Underlying event parameterization
Background estimation from MC
Try to be as independent from MC as possible.
Detector pessimistic scenarios
Partly or non-working b-tagging at startup
Dead regions in the LArg
Jet energy scale
Get good ‘feel’ for important systematic uncertainties – use data to check data
Software tools
Many studies (not all!) only in fast simulation
It is clear we need to redo most important studies with full simulation
Estimate realistic potential for top physics during the first few months of running
Stan Bentvelsen Commissioning Meeting Freiburg
P6
Status of top event generators
‘Old’ Leading Order MC:
Pythia: full standalone MC
Herwig: full standalone MC
TopRex (include spin correlations – interfaced to Pythia)
‘New’ NLO QCD calculations implemented in MC
MC@NLO – interfaced to Herwig shower and fragmentation
This is relevant theoretical improvement
Superseeds the old Pythia and Herwig MC’s.
Validation done for this generator
Currently DC2 processes 106 MC@NLO t-tbar events
Crucial for us to analyse these
Waiting for Tier0 exercise to obtain reconstructed objects
Stan Bentvelsen Commissioning Meeting Freiburg
P7
Generators: MC@NLO, Herwig, Pythia
Example: distributions on top-anti-top characteristic – PT of the whole system
PT of t-tbar system is balanced by ISR & FSR
PT(tt system)
Herwig & MCatNLO agree at low PT,
At large PT MCatNLO ‘harder’
PYTHIA completely off
Many more comparisons:
see talks in top meeting
Stan Bentvelsen Commissioning Meeting Freiburg
P8
Underlying event (UE) / minimum bias
Extremely difficult to predict the magnitude of the UE
at LHC
Will have to learn much more from Tevatron before startup
Various models exists
Herwig’s UE and minimum bias shows much less activity compared
to Pythia.
This has always been a problem in Herwig.
Jimmy is developed as alternative model for UE at ep collisions
Various ‘tunings’ exist – leading to wildly different results
More work is mandatory here
Wish list to generate fully simulated events with Jimmy during DC2
post-production
Stan Bentvelsen Commissioning Meeting Freiburg
P9
Tune of
Butterworth
Standard
Jimmy
Standard
Pythia
Standard
Herwig
Running at LHC energies
Stan Bentvelsen Commissioning Meeting Freiburg
P 10
Jimmy UE: Cells & Jets in Atlfast
Herwig vs Jimmy
LO t-tbar
Cell multiplicity
Cluster multiplicity
Jet multiplicity
At jet-level effect
reduced
10 GeV
Stan Bentvelsen Commissioning Meeting Freiburg
P 11
Reconstruct the top
Top peak for various reconstruction
methods
Difference in mass can be as large
as 5 GeV
Really need data to check data on UE
Study effect better (as said)
Stan Bentvelsen Commissioning Meeting Freiburg
P 12
Background events
Top physics background
AlpGen W+4 jets samples produced
Mistags or fake tags
Non-W (QCD)
W+jets, Wbbar, Wccbar
Wc
WW,WZ,ZZ
Z tt
Single top
Largest background is W+4 jet.
This background cannot be simulated
by Pythia or Herwig shower process.
Dedicated generator needed: e.g.
AlpGen. Large uncertainties in rate
Ultimately, get this rate from data
itself. For example, measure Z+4 jets
rate in data, and determine ratio
(Z+4 jets)/(W+4 jets) from MC
Very CPU intense (NIKHEF grid)
Un-weighting to W lepton (e,,) decay
Production:
Effective : 2430 pb
380740 unweighted events generated
(2.6 10-5 efficiency)
3.41% (13002) events pass first selection
~ 150 pb-1 W+4jet background available
W+4 extra light jets
Jet: Pt>10, ||<2.5, R>0.4
No lepton cuts
Initial grid: 200000*3
Events: 150·106
~1.5 1010
Jobs: 98
events!
Stan Bentvelsen Commissioning Meeting Freiburg
P 13
Non-W (QCD-multijet) background
Not possible to realistically generate this background
Crucially depends on Atlas’ capabilities to minimize
mis-identification and increase e/ separation
This background has to be obtained from data itself
E.g. method developed by CDF during run-1:
Use missing ET vs lepton isolation to define 4 regions:
A. Low lepton quality and small missing ET
Mostly non-W events (i.e. QCD background)
B. High lepton quality and small missing ET
Observation reduction QCD background by lepton quality cuts
C. Low lepton quality and high missing ET
W enriched sample with a fraction of QCD background
D. High lepton quality and high missing ET
W enriched sample, fraction of QCD estimated by (B·C)/(A·D)
Rely now on e/ separation of 10-5
Stan Bentvelsen Commissioning Meeting Freiburg
P 14
Detector scenarios: HV problems
Effects of dead HV regions om Mtop
Argon gap (width ~ 4 mm) is split in two half gaps by the electrode
HV by Dη x Dφ = 0.2 x 0.2 (or 0.1 x 0.2) sectors, separately in each
half gap
~ 33 / 1024 sectors where we may be unable to set the HV on one
half gap multiply energy by 2 to recover
particle
A.I. Etienvre, J.P.
Meyer, J.Schwindling
Stan Bentvelsen Commissioning Meeting Freiburg
P 15
Analysis
100 000 tt events (~ 1.5 days at LHC at low L)
EM
clusters
o Simulated using PYTHIA + ATLSIM
/ G3 (initial detector, h < 3.2)
o Reconstructed using ATHENA 7.0.0
Preselection of events:
o At least one recontructed e or μ
with PT > 20 GeV and η < 2.5
o ETmiss > 20 GeV
o At least 4 jets with PT > 20 GeV and h < 2.5
Jets
Stan Bentvelsen Commissioning Meeting Freiburg
P 16
Results
If the 33 weak HV sectors die
(very pessimistic), the effects on the
top mass measurement, after a crude
recalibration, are:
o Loss of signal: < 8 %
o Increase in background:
not studied
o Displacement of the peak of the
mass distribution: -0.2 GeV
Mtop(without ) – mtop(with dead regions)
This effect on the Top mass is (much) better known than other
systematic uncertainties
Stan Bentvelsen Commissioning Meeting Freiburg
P 17
Detector scenarios: b-tagging
Precise alignment of ID can be reached only after few months
of data taking.
The impact of misalignment can be much larger than having 2 instead
of 3 layers
Top events to evaluate b-tagging efficiencies from data
Select a pure t-tbar sample with tight kinematical cuts
Count the number of events with at least 1 tagged jet
Compare 0 vs 1 vs 2 b-tagged jets in top events
Can expect the b-tagging efficiency different in data from MC
In most pessimistic scenario b-tagging is absent at start
Can we observe the top without b-tagging?
Stan Bentvelsen Commissioning Meeting Freiburg
P 18
Non b-tag tops
t bjj
V. Kostiouchine
Selection:
M (bjj)
Isolated lepton with PT>20 GeV
Exactly 4 jets (R=0.4) with PT>40 GeV
Reconstruction:
Select 3 jets with maximal resulting PT
Stan Bentvelsen Commissioning Meeting Freiburg
P 19
Non btag: top sample
Most important background for top: W+4 jets
Leptonic decay of W, with 4 extra ‘light’ jets
Signal plus background at initial
phase of LHC
L = 150 pb-1
(2/3 days low lumi)
With extreme simple
selection and
reconstruction the
top-peak should be
visible at LHC
Stan Bentvelsen Commissioning Meeting Freiburg
P 20
Extraction of top signal
Fit to signal and background
Gaussian signal
4th order polynomal Chebechev background
In this fit the width of top is fixed at 12 GeV
150 pb-1
Extract
cross section
and Mtop?
Stan Bentvelsen Commissioning Meeting Freiburg
P 21
Can we see the W? (4 jets sample)
Select the 2 jets with highest
resulting PT
W peak visible in signal
No peak in background
Better ideas well possible!
E.g. utilizing 2 body decay in
top rest frame.
150 pb-1
Select 2 jets with invariant
mass closest to Mw
(80.4 GeV)
Large peak in background
Enormous bias
Not useable!
Stan Bentvelsen Commissioning Meeting Freiburg
P 22
Fit to W mass
Fit signal and background also
possible for W-mass
Not easy to converge fit
Fix W width to 6 GeV
150 pb-1
mean
σ(stat)
in peak 3.0%
5%
Mtop
167.0
0.8
Mw
77.8
0.7
These numbers for
statistical uncertainties
are consistent to the
earlier study
Stan Bentvelsen Commissioning Meeting Freiburg
P 23
Jet Energy scale / MC dependence
Variation of the jet energy scale to infer
systematics
Bjet scale: 0.92 – 0.96 – 1.00 – 1.04 – 1.08
Light scale: 0.94 – 0.98 – 1.00 – 1.02 – 1.04
(1) (2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
2)
3)
Analysis with jet energy
scaled
All with MC@NLO, Herwig
and Pythia;
Redo analysis with doubled
W+4jet background (stat indep)
Dependence on top mass reduced by scaling
with W:
Rms Raw:
6.2 GeV
Rms Scaled:
1.2 GeV
Large dependence σ(top) on jet energy scale
Cross section
Via event selection.
Top mass
1200
180
1000
175
Top mass
1)
Determine Mtop and σ(top)
‘Raw’, i.e. no correction for jet scale
‘Corrected’, i.e. apply percentage
difference of W-peak to the reconstructed
top
800
170
Raw Top Mass
Scaled Top Mass
Cross section
600
165
400
160
200
155
0
5
10
15
Scale variations
20
25
0
0
5
10
15
20 Meeting25Freiburg
Stan
Bentvelsen
Commissioning
P 24
Some results… (still no b-tag)
How to judge these values?
Using 150 pb-1 of data:
Statistic uncertainty already
smaller than these systematic
variations
mean
Mtop
Stat
Systematics overestimated:
std
raw
168,1
0.8
6,2
3,7%
corrected
171,9
0.8
1,2
0,7%
Systematics underestimated:
percent
σ(top)
raw
817,2
5%
94,8
11,6%
Note these numbers are very
preliminary –
Luminosity uncertainty (15-20%)
to be added!
since all generators are used,
with all energy scales; double
counting
W+4jets rate can be measured
from data
No real FSR variation
No other backgrounds
(e.g. WW, QCD)
Trigger
Non-uniformities
Need further detailed studies!
Please don’t thrust any of this
without Full simulation
Stan Bentvelsen Commissioning Meeting Freiburg
P 25
Lower luminosity?
Go down to 30 pb-1
Both W and T peaks already
observable
See something!
30 pb-1
30 pb-1
mean
σ(stat)
in peak 0.8%
17%
Mtop
170.0
3.2
Mw
78.3
1.0
Stan Bentvelsen Commissioning Meeting Freiburg
P 26
Fit the lepton+hadronic top
Full kinematic fit to t-tbar system – no b-tagging
Fit the neutrino Px and Py - and get Pz via W constraint
Use W-mass constraints
Require equal top masses for lepton and hadron side
Repeat fit over all possible combinations of jets
Better suited for mass than for cross section
Looks promising but further study needed…
Background
shows structure
Cut on quality of
fit (X2)
E. Bos
Stan Bentvelsen Commissioning Meeting Freiburg
P 27
What with b-tagging on?
Now assume full b-tagging
Efficiency 60%, mistag 1%
Background is rapidly decreasing
See for example the W-mass peaks for 1 and 2 b-tags
Same selection: 4 jet events
W reconstructed as dijet mass; |Mjj-80.4| minimal for light-jets j
150 pb-1
Stan Bentvelsen Commissioning Meeting Freiburg
P 28
Reconstruct top mass
Sharp top mass peaks with little background
Only use events for which |Mjj-80.4| < 20 GeV
Standard kinematic top reconstruction for 1 and 2 b-tags
Background from W+4jets removed by b-tag requirement
These results are very sensitive to b mis-tag rate
150 pb-1
Stan Bentvelsen Commissioning Meeting Freiburg
P 29
Mtt at startup?
Can we determine dσ(tt)/dmtt without b-tagging?
Mtt is invariant mass over all final state to tt products
Interesting to SuSy models that modify this cross section
In principle no
assignment of
b-jet to top is
needed
Suffer a lot
from background
W+4jet
background
No reliable
measurement
of mtt without
b-tagging
Stan Bentvelsen Commissioning Meeting Freiburg
P 30
Resonances decaying to t-tbar
Observe heavy resonances Xt-tbar during commissioning?
Plot invariant mass of 4 jets + lepton + neutrino
No intelligence in determining Pz neutrino here
Insert resonance at 2000 GeV
Cross section * BR(tt) = 350 pb
Heavy resonances with
large cross sections visible
‘True’ mtt distributions of
resonance and ttbar events
Stan Bentvelsen Commissioning Meeting Freiburg
P 31
Need checks with full simulation
We are eagerly waiting for reconstructed DC2 events
Repeat with full simulation for Rome next year
Stan Bentvelsen Commissioning Meeting Freiburg
P 32
Top group in Atlas:
Inputs to the top group
Estimate of the single electron
trigger efficiency
At the beginning the precision on L
should be around 10-20%.
The ultimate precision should be <
5%
A “pure” one, obtained with quite
tight selection criteria
A “loose” one: a more “background
enriched” sample, to be used as
control sample for background
calculations etc…
Estimate of a light jet energy scale
correction
Estimate of the integrated
luminosity
Top candidates enriched samples
Can be done by using the Z
triggered as single electron
How much time is needed to arrive
to a reasonable evaluation of this
efficiency?
Estimate of the initial lepton
identification efficiency
What we have to provide
Assume 10% for light and b-quark
jets, look at effect on Mtop and stop
Assume that at the very beginning
only the EM scale is known (means:
do not put any weight on the
hadronic scale)
Output: provide the MW peak to
rescale the light jets
Eventually:
B-tagging efficiency
Jet scales
Estimate of the b-tagging efficiency
Stan Bentvelsen Commissioning Meeting Freiburg
P 33
Summary / Conclusion
Understand the interplay between using the top signal as tool to improve
the understanding of the detector (b-tagging, jet E scale, ID, etc..) and
top precision measurements
At LHC Top more easily found than W’s in 4 jet channel
Using few days of data taking (150 pb-1)
Using extreme simple selection, no b-tagging
Need more work on background estimation, both from W’s and QCD, e/
ratio, trigger, lepton ID, etc …
Remove dependence of results on MC as much as possible
Current estimate on cross section accuracy of (ball park) 10%
plus luminosity uncertainty
Interestingly mass of top via fits to mass peak looks promising
(use W-mass as constraint to jet-scale)
Need better ideas to isolate very pure top sample without b-tagging
Its clear we need full simulation
Eagerly awaiting reconstructed DC2 events to repeat/extend these studies
Stan Bentvelsen Commissioning Meeting Freiburg