Transcript Slide 1

Denny Vitasari, Paul Grassia, Peter Martin
Annual Manchester SIAM Student Chapter Conference 2013
20 May 2013
1
Background – Foam fractionation
• Foam fractionation:
Separation of surface
active material using
rising column of
foam.
Transport of surfactant
onto the film interface
determines the
efficiency of a foam
fractionation column.
• Foam fractionation
column with reflux:
Some of the top
product is returned to
the column.
2
Foam structure – Dry foam
Lamella:
thin film
separating the
air bubbles
within foam.
Plateau border:
three lamellae meet
at 120 to form an
edge.
3
2D illustration of a foam lamella
• Due to reflux, the surface tension at the Plateau border (Pb) is lower than
that at the lamella (F)  transport of surfactant from the surface of
Plateau border to the surface of film  Marangoni effect.
• Pressure in the Plateau border is lower due to curvature (Young-Laplace
law)  liquid is sucked to the Plateau border  film drainage.
4
Assumptions
• The lamella is always flat
and has a uniform
thickness along the length.
• At initial time the surface
concentration (F0) of
surfactant along the film is
uniform.
• The surface
concentration (Pb) of
surfactant at the Plateau
border interface is fixed.
5
Film velocity profile
viscosity
The equation for velocity profile of liquid on
the lamella surface:
𝑥 d𝛿 1 𝛿 𝜕𝛾
𝑢𝑠 = −
+
𝛿 d𝑡 3 𝜇 𝜕𝑥
Film drainage
Surfactant mass balance:
Gibbs-Marangoni
parameter
Marangoni effect
𝜕Γ
𝜕Γ
1 d𝛿 𝐺 𝜕 2 Γ
= 𝑥
+Γ
+
𝜕𝑡
𝜕𝑥
𝛿 d𝑡 3𝜇 𝜕𝑥 2
6
Rate of film drainage
• Mobile interface (Breward-Howell, 20021)
d𝛿
3 𝛾𝑃𝑏 𝛿 3 2
=−
d𝑡
8 𝜇𝐿 𝑎
• Rigid interface (Reynolds, 18862)
d𝛿
𝛾𝑃𝑏 𝛿 3
=−
d𝑡
3𝜇𝐿2 𝑎
1. Breward, CJW and Howell, PD, Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 458:379-406, 2002
2. Reynolds, O, Philosophical Transaction of the Royal Society of London, 177:157-234, 1886
7
Analytical solution
Case no film drainage
Solution of surfactant mass balance equation:
Complementary error function
• Shift one boundary condition to - and solve the equation analytically to result in
a complementary error function.
• Reflection method to correct the boundary condition.
• Violation of boundary condition due to reflection method.
• Improving accuracy using additional reflections.
Surfactant mass balance:
Boundary conditions:
Complementary error function (1 reflection):
8
Analytical solution
Case no film drainage
Solution of surfactant mass balance equation:
Fourier series
Fourier series obtained from method of separation variable:
Surfactant mass balance:
Boundary conditions:
Fourier series:
9
Numerical simulation
of surfactant concentration ()
Material point method3
•
The surface velocity (us) applies on
every material point  material point
change its position.
•
Surface excess () averages between
two material points.
•
Surfactant is conserved  same area of
the rectangle.
3. Embley, B and Grassia, P, Colloids and Surfaces A, 382: 8-17, 2011
10
Bookkeeping operation
•
Every time step: material points change their positions  uneven
spatial interval over time.
•
The spatial interval (Δx) is restored and the value of  is corrected.
•
Take a weighted average of  in the restored interval as the new
value.
both sides move to the right
left side moves to the right
right side moves to the left
both sides move to the left
11
Analytical solution
Case with film drainage
(Quasi) steady state (rigid interface):
us = 0 (no surfactant flux on the surface)
Solution:
Asymptotic solution (mobile interface):
Uniform inner solution inner pulls boundary layer near the
Plateau border
Solution:
12
Parameters for simulation
Parameter
Symbol
Value
Unit
Characteristic `Marangoni’ time scale
L2/(G0)
3.12510-2
s
Characteristic thinning time scale (mobile)
0/(d/dt)0
1.4810-3
s
Characteristic thinning time scale (rigid)
0/(d/dt)0
2.08
s
Initial half lamella thickness
0
2010-6
m
Half lamella length
L
510-3
m
Liquid viscosity

110-3
Pa s
Curvature radius of the Plateau border
a
510-4
m
Surfactant surface concentration at PB
Pb
210-6
mol m-2
Initial surface concentration at film
film
110-6
mol m-2
Surface tension of solution at PB
Pb
4510-3
N m-1
Gibbs-Marangoni parameter
G
4010-3
N m-1
13
Results
dimensionless form
14
Surface excess profile ( vs x)
no film drainage
t
Surface excess of surfactant () increases with time
15
Verification of numerical result
Case no film drainage
Complementary error function
• t’ = 0.005
• Simulation at early
time  fewer
reflection terms
needed.
• Numerical simulation
fits well with the
analytical solution.
16
Verification of numerical result
Case no film drainage
Fourier series
• t’ = 2
• Simulation at later
time  fewer Fourier
terms needed.
• Numerical simulation
fits well with the
analytical solution.
• Accuracy of the
numerical result
increases with more
grid elements.
17
Surface excess profile ( vs x)
film drainage: rigid interface
t
Surface excess of surfactant () increases with time but
slightly more slowly than in case with no film drainage.
18
Surface excess profile ( vs x)
film drainage: mobile interface
t
Surface excess of surfactant () decreases with time:
surfactant washed off film by film drainage.
19
Spatially-averaged surface excess 
• Surface excess 
increases with time for the
case of no drainage and
draining film with a rigid
interface.
• Surface excess 
decreases with time for
the case of draining film
with a mobile interface.
• Surface excess  of
draining film with a rigid
interface is slightly lower
than that of no drainage.
20
(Quasi) steady state solution
Film drainage: rigid interface
• The (quasi) static
solution has weak
spatial variation in .
• Quasi static solution
does not significantly
change with time.
• Agreement between
numerical and (quasi)
static solution only
possible at reasonably
long time.
21
Asymptotic boundary-layer solution
Film drainage: mobile interface
• Inner region (near the
film centre) and outer
region (near the Plateau
border).
• Inner region: Marangoni
effect is negligible.
• Outer region: Marangoni
effect is retained.
• Agreement between
numerical and
asymptotic analytical
results.
22
Conclusions
• The equations of surfactant transport onto a foam lamella can be
solved numerically using a material point method followed by a
bookkeeping operation.
• The numerical simulation is validated by analytical solution obtained
from complementary error function and Fourier series in the case of
no film drainage.
• In a foam fractionation column with reflux, when Marangoni flow
dominates the film drainage, the surface concentration of surfactant
increases with time.
• When film drainage dominates the Marangoni effect such as in a film
with mobile interface, surfactant is washed away to Plateau border
and its concentration decreases with time.
• Quasi steady state solution agreed with the numerical simulation for
the case of a film with a rigid interface, in the limit of long times.
• Asymptotic boundary-layer solution agreed with the numerical
simulation for the case of a film with a mobile interface.
23
24