Transcript Ethics and Social Responsibility
Chapter 4
Ethics and Social Responsibility
Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved 1
Ethical and Unethical Workplace Behavior
Ethics The set of moral principles or values that defines right and wrong for a person or group.
Question: it an act is illegal, is it unethical by default?
Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved 3
ETHICS: MURKIER THAN YOU THINK
Legal and Unethical
Promoting R-rated movies to young teens Producing products that you know will break before their time Paying non-living wages to workers in developing countries Ford Pinto case
Illegal and Unethical
Embezzling money Engaging in sexual harassment Practicing Collusion with competitors Encouraging fraudulent accounting Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved
Legal and Ethical
Producing high quality products Rewarding integrity Leading by example Treating employees fairly Contributing to the community Respecting the environment
Illegal and Ethical
Providing rock-bottom prices only to distributors in underserved areas Collaborating with other medical clinics to guarantee low prices in low-income countries (collusion) Parking in a no-parking zone
UNIVERSAL ETHICAL STANDARDS
Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved Developed by
Character
Counts, a nonpartisan organization of educators, community leaders, and ethicists.
Ethics and the Nature of Management Jobs
Unethical Managerial Behavior
Authority and Power Handling Information Influencing the Behavior of Others Setting Goals 1
Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved 7
Workplace Deviance
Workplace Deviance Unethical behavior that violates organizational norms about right and wrong
Two dimensions
Degree of deviance Target of deviant behavior 2
Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved 9
Types of Workplace Deviance
Organizational Production Deviance
Negative impact on production….
Minor
Causing political harm to others…
Political Deviance 2 Interpersonal
Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved
Property Deviance
Misuse of corporate property….
Serious
Personal aggression
Personal Aggression
Adapted from Exhibit 4.1
10
Production Deviance
Leaving early Taking excessive breaks Intentionally working slowly Wasting resources
2
Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved 11
Property Deviance
Sabotaging equipment Accepting kickbacks Lying about hours worked Stealing from company
2
Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved 12
Political Deviance
Showing favoritism Gossiping about coworkers Blaming coworkers Competing nonbeneficially
2
Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved 13
Personal Aggression
Sexual harassment Verbal abuse Stealing from coworkers Endangering coworkers
2
Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved 14
U.S. Sentencing Commission Guidelines
Companies can be prosecuted and punished even if management didn’t know about the unethical behavior.
3
Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved 15
Who, What, and Why?
Nearly all businesses are covered Punishes a number of offenses Encourages businesses to be proactive
3.1
Includes all businesses, nonprofits, partnerships, labor unions, unincorporated organizations and associations, incorporated organizations and even pension funds, trusts, and joint stock companies.
16 Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved
Partial List of Offenses
Invasion of privacy Price fixing Fraud Customs violations Antitrust violations Civil rights violations Theft
3.1
Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved Money laundering Conflicts of interest Embezzlement Dealing in stolen goods Copyright infringements Extortion
…and more
17
Compliance Program Steps
Steps in determining fine size 1.
determine the base fine 2.
compute a culpability score 3.
multiply the base fine by the culpability score
Smaller fines for companies that are proactive
3.2
Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved 18
Compliance Program Steps
1. Establish standards and procedures.
2. Assign upper-level managers to be in charge.
3. Delegate decision-making authority only to ethical employees.
4. Encourage employees to report violations. 5. Train employees on standards and procedures. 6. Enforce standards consistently and fairly. 3.2
7. Improve program after violations.
Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved 19 Adapted from Exhibit 4.3
Influences on Ethical Decision Making
Ethical Intensity of Decision Ethical Answers Depend on… Moral Development of Manager Ethical Principles Used 4
Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved 21
Ethical Intensity Depends on…
4.1
Magnitude of consequences
Total harm or benefit derived from an ethical decision
Social consensus
Agreement on whether behavior is bad or good.
Probability of effect
The chance that something will happen and harm others
Temporal immediacy
The time between an act and the consequences of the act.
Proximity of effect
Social, psychological, cultural or physical distance of a decision maker to those affected by his/her decisions.
Concentration of effect
How much the act affects the average person.
22 Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved
Moral Development
Kohlberg’s Stages of Moral Development Preconventional Selfish Conventional Postconventional Societal Expectations Internal:
You have a conscious….
Internalized Principles 4.2
Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved Adapted from Exhibit 4.4
24
Stages of Moral Development
You are given a copy of Microsoft Office 2010. Should you copy it to your system?
Preconventional Conventional Postconventional 1. Punishment and Obedience 3. Good boy, nice girl 5. Social contract 2. Instrumental Exchange 4. Law and order 6. Universal principle 4.2
It’s against the law, so I will not copy the software.
it.
This will really help me, so I copy the wrong rule, regardless of the Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved will do it also..
so I do not copy the software.
25
4.3
Principles of Ethical Decision Making (Larue Hosmer)
Long-term self-interest Personal virtue Religious injunctions Government requirements Utilitarian benefits Individual rights Distributive justice
Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved 26
Consider an example
One winter morning, Richard Addessi (an IBM employee) showered, shaved and dressed for the office. Before he could get to his car, he fell dead on the garage floor of a sudden heart attack. Addessi was four months short of his 30-year anniversary with the company, at which he could have retired. Given that he was only four months short of full retirement, do you award full retirement benefits to Addessi’s wife and daughters? If yes, they will receive his full retirement benefits of $1800/month and free lifetime medical coverage. If no, they will receive only $340/month and will have to pay $473 a month just to continue their current medical coverage. What would be the ethical thing to do?
Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved
Principles of Ethical Decision Making
Principle of long-term self-interest Never take any action not in your organization’s long-term self-interest.
4.3
Under this principle, IBM should NOT award offer the retirement benefits to Mrs. Addessi, since IBM always has thousands of employees this close to Retirement.
28 Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved
Principles of Ethical Decision Making
Principle of Personal Virtue Never do anything that is not honest, open, and truthful and that you would not be glad to see reported in the newspapers or on TV.
Under this principle, IBM should have quietly offered the benefits to Mrs. Addessi. Who needs this type of publicity?
4.3
Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved 29
Principles of Ethical Decision Making
Principle of Religious Injunctions Never take any action that is not kind and that does not build a sense of community.
4.3
Under this principle, IBM should offer the benefits To Mrs. Addessi out of compassion and kindness.
30 Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved
Principles of Ethical Decision Making
Principle of Government Requirements Never take any action that violates the law, for the law represents the minimal moral standard.
4.3
Using this principle, IBM would deny full benefits to Mrs. Addessi, since her husband did not qualify for them.
31 Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved
Principles of Ethical Decision Making
Principle of Utilitarian Benefit Never take any action that does not result in greater good for society.
4.3
Using this principle, IBM should deny benefits, Since by doing so with regularity might result in Cutting stock dividend, hurting millions.
32 Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved
Principles of Ethical Decision Making
Principle of Individual Rights Never take any action that infringes on others’ agreed-upon rights.
4.3
Using this principle, IBM should deny benefits, Since offering them could be perceived as Violating the rights of other employees who Had to wait 30 years to receive the same benefits.
33 Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved
Principles of Ethical Decision Making
Principle of Distributive Justice Never take any action that harms the least among us: the poor, the uneducated, the unemployed.
Using this principle, IBM would award Mrs.
Addessi full benefits.
4.3
Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved 34
Practical Steps to Ethical Decision Making
Select and hire ethical employees Establish a Code of Ethics Train employees to make ethical decisions Create an ethical climate 5
Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved 35
Practical Steps to Ethical Decision Making
Select and hire ethical employees
If you found a wallet containing $50, would you return it with the money?
Overt Integrity Tests Personality-Based Integrity Tests
5.1
Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved 36
Practical Steps to Ethical Decision Making
Establish a Code of Ethics
Communicate code of ethics to those both inside and outside the company Develop ethical standards and procedures specific to your business
5.2
Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved 42
Ethics Training
Ethics Training
Develops employee awareness of ethics Achieves credibility with employees Teaches a practical model of ethical decision making
5.3
Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved 43
Ethics Training
Tower Records Lockheed Boeing Bell South U.S. Dept. of Justice 3M TCU And more require employees to take ethics training
44 Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved
5.3
A Basic Model of Ethical Decision Making
1. Identify the problem 2. Identify the constituents 3. Diagnose the situation 4. Analyze your options 5. Make your choice 6. Act
Who has been hurt? Who could be hurt? Who could be helped? Are How did it happen in the first place? What could have prevented it? Is fairness, relationships, and integrity. How would you define the the likely costs? Look to the company mission statement or code of problem if you stood on the other side of the fence?
ethics for guidance.
Ethical Climate
Establishing an Ethical Climate
Managers:
5.4
1. Act ethically 2. Are active in company ethics programs 3. Report potential ethics violations 4. Punish those who violate the code of ethics
Web Link
http://www.whistleblowers.org
46 Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved
What Is Social Responsibility?
Social Responsibility
A business’s obligation to…
pursue policies make decisions take actions that benefit society
48 Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved
What Is Social Responsibility?
Recall from Chapter 3 that PETA and Procter & Gamble have an ongoing disagreement about what is socially responsible.
Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved 49
To Whom Are Organizations Socially Responsible?
Shareholder Model Maximize Profits Stakeholder Model Satisfy Interests of Multiple Stakeholders 6
Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved 50
Stakeholder Model
Primary Stakeholders:
Shareholders Employees Customers Suppliers Governments Local Communities
Secondary Stakeholders:
Media Special Interest Groups Trade Associations 6
Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved 52
Organization’s Social Responsibilities
Serve a social role Abide by principles of right and wrong Obey laws and regulations Be profitable 7
Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved
Discretionary Ethical ?
Legal Economic $
53
Responses to Demands for Social Responsibility
Reactive Fight all the way Withdrawal Defensive Do only what is required Public Relations Approach Accommo dative Be progressive Legal Approach Bargaining Proactive Lead the industry Problem Solving DO NOTHING 8
Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved 54
DO MUCH
Social Responsibility and Economic Performance
Realities of Social Responsibility Can cost a company Sometimes it does pay Does not guarantee profitability 9
Chapter 4 Copyright ©2009 by Cengage Learning Inc. All rights reserved 55