Transcript Tachyon – Faster than light particles
There was a young lady named Bright, Whose speed was far faster than light.
She went out one day, In a relative way, And returned the previous night!
— Reginald Buller
Tachyon – Faster than light particles
Overview
Background – the idea Concept – Theory Problems – Antitelephone Research – Discovery?
Conclusion
Background
ταχύς or tachys, meaning "swift, quick, fast, rapid“coined by Gerald Feinberg Theoretical propositions of Tachyons by George Sudarshan in 1962 Not consistent with the known laws of physics Could be used to build a tachyonic antitelephone – violate causality
The Idea
1967 – Gerald Feinberg in "On the possibility of faster-than-light particles" Quanta of a quantum field with negative squared mass (complex mass) Draw Energy and momentum graph Draw “light cone” – lines with E = ±p
The Idea - Relativity
Fundamental relativity fact E² − p² = m²; simplify c=1 Any particle with mass m falls in this hyperbola Massless particles have E² = p² and move on the cone Point (0,m) is when particles are at rest
The Idea – Relativity
Another relativistic equation E = m[1−(v/c)²] −½ Tachyons would have v>c E is imaginary!
Take m to be imaginary, E is negative real E² − p² = m² < 0 Hyperbola branching sideways
In timelike space, E and p are proportional In spacelike, as p increase E decrease
Problems – Large energy
Increase in p leads to decrease in E which leads to increase in p If charged tachyons move at v>c, they produce Cherenkov radiation Causes them to lose energy p increases even more!
Also, minimum v=c
Problems – antitelephone paradox
Since tachyons’ v>c, they seemingly can travel back in time Send messages to the past by using tachyons as information carrier Imagine Dave and Jason moving away from each other at speed close to c Diagram for using normal carriers
Using tachyons – Dave
At t=1.5s Dave sends message Because of time dilation, t=1.3 for Jason Not surprising because of relativity
Using tachyons – Jason
Because of tachyons’ speed, Jason receives message before seeing Dave sending it
Using tachyons – Jason
Say Jason sends a message back
Using tachyons Dave
He receives the Jason’s message before sending the first message!
Research
Can be assigned normal matter properties like spin Modern presentations allows tachyons to have mass Could be produced from high-energy particle collisions Search tachyons in cosmic rays 1973 - Philip Crough and Roger Clay identified a putative superluminal particle in an air shower Results were never reproduced
Research – not impossible?
Einstein’s theory does not prevent apparent v>c E.g. phase velocity and group velocity of a wave may exceed the speed of light, but no energy or information actually travels faster than c Can obtain superluminal solutions to Maxwell equation Do not violate causality because wavefronts travel within c
Research
1985 – Chodos et al. proposed neutrinos as tachyonic Modeled using Lorentz invariance Neutrinos experience Lorentz-violating oscillations and can travel faster than light at high energies Strongly criticized
Research – discovery?
September 2011 Oscillation Project with Emulsion-tRacking Apparatus (OPERA) observed muon neutrinos travelling at v>c Repeated experiments concluded this was an error in
Conclusion
Theoretically, tachyons might still be probable Modern calculations still hint probability Not a popular idea because of Einstein’s theory Does not stop some scientists from searching for it Real or not, it is very interesting
Resources
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tachyon http://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/physics/ParticleAndNuclear/tachy ons.html
http://scienceworld.wolfram.com/physics/Tachyon.html
http://io9.com/5846519/do-faster-than-light-neutrinos-let-you change-the-past http://scienceworld.wolfram.com/physics/X-Wave.html