SMS Non Conformance Reporting Procedure

Download Report

Transcript SMS Non Conformance Reporting Procedure

SAFETY MANAGEMENT
SYSTEM
Non Conformance Reporting
2009
CANADIAN
CANADIANCOAST
COASTGUARD
GUARDAUXILIARY
AUXILIARY- -PACIFIC
PACIFIC
Non Conformances /
Observations
• Used wherever an accident occurs to a
person or a vessel, or a procedure in the
Safety Management System is found not to
work, or is not being followed.
• They can be initiated by anyone, but would
usually be a Coxswain, Station Leader,
Manager, or internal or external auditor.
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Non Conformances /
Observations
• Major Non Conformance – Issues where
corrective action must be carried out
immediately to meet the ISM Code, failure to
do so would result in the withdrawal of the
Safety Management Certificate and/or the
Company Document of Compliance.
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Non Conformances /
Observations
• Non Conformances – Issues where
corrective action must be made to meet the
ISM Code and/or ensure that the Procedures
in the Safety Management System onboard
are being followed correctly.
• Time limited.
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Non Conformances /
Observations
• Observations – Issues where improvements
in the Safety Management System and
procedures are recommended.
• These do not have to be complied with,
however they should be considered.
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Handling of Non Conformances /
Observations
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Non Conformance System
• In the following the Process Owner is the
Manager responsible for the area of operation
that went wrong in the accident.
• e.g. The SAR Operations Manager is
responsible for the Marine Operations
Manual.
• More than one Process Owner may be
involved as well as the Executive Officer.
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Non Conformance System 1
President
1. Non Conformance
originated
Executive
Officer
4
3
9
5
Safety
Manager
2
6
5
4
Manager
(Process Owner)
8
1
Station
Leader 7
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Coxswain
Non Conformance System 2
President
2. Station Leader
contacts Safety
Manager with non
conformance and
suggested
corrective action
Executive
Officer
4
3
9
5
Safety
Manager
2
6
5
4
Manager
(Process Owner)
8
1
Station
Leader 7
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Coxswain
Non Conformance System 3
President
3. Safety Manager
assigns number
and enters NonConformance
Report into
database.
Executive
Officer
4
3
9
5
Safety
Manager
2
6
5
4
Manager
(Process Owner)
8
1
Station
Leader 7
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Coxswain
Non Conformance System 4
President
4. Safety Manager
copies NonConformance
Report to
appropriate
Manager/ Process
Owner.
Executive
Officer
4
3
9
5
Safety
Manager
2
6
5
4
Manager
(Process Owner)
8
1
Station
Leader 7
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Coxswain
Non Conformance System 5
President
5. Managers /
Process Owner
agree and decide
on appropriate
Corrective Action
Executive
Officer
4
3
9
5
Safety
Manager
2
6
5
4
Manager
(Process Owner)
8
1
Station
Leader 7
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Coxswain
Non Conformance System 6
President
6. Station informed of
Corrective Action
Executive
Officer
4
3
9
5
Safety
Manager
2
6
5
4
Manager
(Process Owner)
8
1
Station
Leader 7
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Coxswain
Non Conformance System 7
President
7. Corrective Action
taken
Executive
Officer
4
3
9
5
Safety
Manager
2
6
5
4
Manager
(Process Owner)
8
1
Station
Leader 7
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Coxswain
Non Conformance System 8
President
8. Notification of
Corrective Action
taken, passed to
Safety Manager
Executive
Officer
4
3
9
5
Safety
Manager
2
6
5
4
Manager
(Process Owner)
8
1
Station
Leader 7
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Coxswain
Non Conformance System 9
President
9. Non-Conformance
closed out
Executive
Officer
4
3
9
5
Safety
Manager
2
6
5
4
Manager
(Process Owner)
8
1
Station
Leader 7
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Coxswain
Non Conformance System
• The corrective action may consist of
modification of:
1. the vessel or some vessels or equipment
2. the procedures covered by the Safety
Management System
3. crew training practices or standards
4. reporting procedures ashore
5. the standard operating procedures at a
station
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Non Conformance System
………or some or all of the above
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Non Conformance System
• The accident and corrective action will be
promulgated as necessary to Managers,
President and the Board.
• They may also be promulgated by use of the
Lessons Learned section of the SAR
Management System.
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Non Conformance System
• If the Safety Manager feels that there is
insufficient support from managers for
particular corrective action that he/ she
deems necessary, the Safety Manager can go
direct to the President with those concerns.
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Scenario
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Scenario
• A dedicated rescue vessel is out on a training
mission, and goes aground at speed, without
damage.
• It safely refloats, without damage, and returns
to its berth.
• The Coxswain will report the fact to the
Station Leader.
• All crew will write witness statements
(preferably separately).
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Scenario - Part 1
President
1. Non Conformance
originated
Executive
Officer
4
3
9
5
Safety
Manager
2
6
5
4
Manager
(Process Owner)
8
1
Station
Leader 7
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Coxswain
Scenario - Part 1
• Under the Safety Management System, the
Station Leader will raise a Non Conformance
Report.
• This can be done initially by telephoning the
Safety Manager, but will be followed up by a
form in writing.
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Scenario - Part 2
President
2. Station Leader
contacts Safety
Manager with non
conformance and
suggested
corrective action
Executive
Officer
4
3
9
5
Safety
Manager
2
6
5
4
Manager
(Process Owner)
8
1
Station
Leader 7
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Coxswain
Scenario - Part 2
• The Station Leader sends the written report
plus statements as soon as possible to the
Safety Manager.
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Scenario - Part 3
President
3. Safety Manager
assigns number
and enters NonConformance
Report into
database.
Executive
Officer
4
3
9
5
Safety
Manager
2
6
5
4
Manager
(Process Owner)
8
1
Station
Leader 7
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Coxswain
Scenario - Part 3
• The Safety Manager inspects the report and
statements, and decides which manager (s)
are responsible for possible corrective action
e.g. SAR Operations and Training Managers,
and also informs the Executive Officer
• The Safety Manager will allocate a sequential
number to the report, and enter summary of
the non conformance in database.
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Scenario - Part 3
• It will be at this stage that the Safety Manager
recommends to the Management Team that
an investigation is to be carried out as soon
as possible into all the circumstances of the
grounding.
• The Safety Manager shall lead this
investigation.
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Scenario - Part 4
President
4. Safety Manager
copies NonConformance
Report to
appropriate
Manager/ Process
Owner.
Executive
Officer
4
3
9
5
Safety
Manager
2
6
5
4
Manager
(Process Owner)
8
1
Station
Leader 7
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Coxswain
Scenario - Part 4
• The relevant information and results of the
investigation will be sent to the appropriate
members of the Management Team, which in
this case will be the SAR Operations
Manager and the Training Manager.
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Scenario - Part 5
President
5. Managers /
Process Owner
agree and decide
on appropriate
Corrective Action
Executive
Officer
4
3
9
5
Safety
Manager
2
6
5
4
Manager
(Process Owner)
8
1
Station
Leader 7
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Coxswain
Scenario - Part 5
• The Training Manager and the SAR
Operations Manager will discuss departure
from any procedures and the scope of the
required corrective action.
• The corrective action may include:
1. an appraisal of the the qualifications, seatime and experience of all crew
2. a more rigorous maintenance requirement of
electronic navigational aids
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Scenario - Part 5
3. more of the designated crew to attend
simulator training
4. compulsory use of certain navigational
techniques
5. etc.
This corrective action is discussed with the
Safety Manager, who has the final say.
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Scenario - Part 6
President
6. Station informed of
Corrective Action
Executive
Officer
4
3
9
5
Safety
Manager
2
6
5
4
Manager
(Process Owner)
8
1
Station
Leader 7
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Coxswain
Scenario - Part 6
• The Safety Manager informs the station of the
necessary corrective action, and co-ordinates
any necessary outside assistance that may
be needed.
• It may be necessary for the appropriate
manager to modify the written procedures
and promulgate them.
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Scenario - Part 7
President
7. Corrective Action
taken
Executive
Officer
4
3
9
5
Safety
Manager
2
6
5
4
Manager
(Process Owner)
8
1
Station
Leader 7
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Coxswain
Scenario - Part 7
• The Station Leader / managers take the
agreed corrective action.
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Scenario - Part 8
President
8. Notification of
Corrective Action
taken, passed to
Safety Manager
Executive
Officer
4
3
9
5
Safety
Manager
2
6
5
4
Manager
(Process Owner)
8
1
Station
Leader 7
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Coxswain
Scenario - Part 8
• The Station Leader / managers inform the
Safety Manager of the completion of the
required corrective action (crew reassessed,
crew retrained, new procedures in place and
all stations informed, ….)
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Scenario - Part 9
President
9. Non-Conformance
closed out
Executive
Officer
4
3
9
5
Safety
Manager
2
6
5
4
Manager
(Process Owner)
8
1
Station
Leader 7
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Coxswain
Scenario - Part 9
• The Safety Manager closes out the Non
Conformance once he/ she is satisfied that
the corrective action is completed, and
informs the Station Leader.
• In addition the Safety Manager can
promulgate the sanitised details of the
accident to the Lessons Learned section of
the SAR Management System, and inform
everyone of its existence.
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Observations
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Observations
• In the case of say a Station Leader alerting
the Safety Manager that a procedure in the
Safety Management System is confusing or
wrong, a similar process will take place (not
involving the President, Executive Officer of
Board) and can probably be closed out in two
weeks or so.
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Summary
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC
Summary
• The emphasis of this procedure is on
continual improvement, and learning from
mistakes.
• The Safety Management System consists of
living documents, which will change as the
organisation grows and matures.
CANADIAN COAST GUARD AUXILIARY - PACIFIC