Social Stratification
Download
Report
Transcript Social Stratification
PowerPoint Presentation
prepared by
Terri Petkau, Mohawk College
CHAPTER SIX
Social Stratification
Harvey Krahn
INTRODUCTION
• Will examine:
Types of stratification systems
Explanations of social stratification
Occupations, social class, and inequality in
Canada
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
Occupational mobility in Canada
Distribution of wealth in Canada
Material inequality and the poor in Canada*
6-3
SOCIAL STRATIFICATION
• Social stratification:
Refers to persistent patterns of social
inequality in a society
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
Is perpetuated by the way wealth, power,
and prestige are distributed and passed
on from one generation to the next
Exists in all societies*
6-4
FEATURES OF SOCIAL
HIERARCHIES
• Status: Rank or position in a social
hierarchy
• Statuses may be:
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
i. Ascribed (assigned at birth), or
ii. Achieved (earned by performance)*
6-5
TYPES OF STRATIFICATION
SYSTEMS
1. Open stratification system:
Stratification system in which merit rather than
inheritance (ascribed characteristics) determines
social rank
Allows for social change
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
• Is reflected in a meritocracy:
Positions are achieved, not ascribed
Characterized by equal opportunity and high
social mobility (movement up or down a social
hierarchy)*
6-6
TYPES OF STRATIFICATION
SYSTEMS
2.
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
Closed stratification system
Stratification system in which inheritance rather
than merit determines social rank
Little social change possible
•
Reflected in a caste system:
Positions are ascribed, not achieved
Characterized by little social mobility
•
Although Canada is in principal a meritocracy,
ascribed statuses still play an important role*
6-7
CLASS AND CLASS
STRUCTURE
• Class: Position in an economic hierarchy
occupied by individuals or families with similar
access to, or control over, material resources
(e.g., working class, professional class)
• Class structure: Relatively permanent economic
hierarchy comprising different social classes
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
• Socioeconomic status: Person’s general status
within an economic hierarchy, based on income,
education, and occupation*
6-8
EXPLANATIONS OF
SOCIAL STRATIFICATION
• Several theories or explanations of social
stratification
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
• Accounts offered by Marx, Weber, Davis
and Moore, Lenski, Wright, and Parkin
Understandings are mediated by time and
place in which social theories developed*
6-9
MARX ON
STRATIFICATION
•
Writings focus particularly on 19th century
European world rapidly being changed by
industrial capitalism
Industrial Revolution: Tremendous increase in
level of economic production and degree of
inequality
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
•
Key concepts in Marx’s theory:
Mode of production: Overall system of economic
activity (e.g., slavery, capitalism)…*
6-10
MARX ON
STRATIFICATION
•
Mode of production comprises:
i.
Means of production: Technology,
capital investments, raw materials
used in production
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
ii. Social relations of production:
Relationships between main classes
involved in production*
6-11
MARX: SOCIAL CLASSES
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
•
Two major classes within industrial capitalism:
i.
The bourgeoisie: Owners of the means of
production
ii.
The proletariat: Workers who exchange their
labour for a wages
•
Secondary class:
The petite bourgeoisie: Independent owners/
producers (e.g., farmers) and small business
owners*
6-12
MARX: EXPLOITATION
• Exploitation of wage labourers was
result of surplus value:
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
When proceeds from sale of goods
produced by wage-labourers far
exceed cost of wages, raw materials,
etc.
Surplus value then turned into profits
for owners (i.e., capitalists)*
6-13
MARX: CLASS CONFLICT
• Class conflict: Conflict between major classes
within a mode of production
Is driving force behind social change
Eventually leads to evolution of new mode of
production
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
• Envisioned capitalism being replaced with
socialist mode of production (i.e., no private
property with its attendant exploitation and
inequality)*
6-14
MARX: CLASS
CONSCIOUSNESS AND
REVOLUTION
• Theorized workers would develop classconsciousness:
Recognition by members of a class of their shared
interest in opposition to members of another class
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
Would lead to revolutionary upheaval and
eventually classes society based on collective
ownership of means of production (e.g.,
communism)*
6-15
RESPONSES TO MARX
•
Criticized for predictions not finding support in:
i.
Later capitalist societies, which were
characterized by absence of widespread class
conflict, growth of the middle class, and relative
decline in material inequality in 20th century
Example: Western Europe and North America
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
ii.
Later socialist systems of government, which
were characterized by persistent inequality, and
new hierarchy that controls political and
bureaucratic apparatus
Example: Russia*
6-16
WEBER ON
STRATIFICATION
•
Focused on determinants of power: Ability to
impose one’s wishes on others
•
i.
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
Structural basis of power:
Class (power derived from position in economic
hierarchy)
ii. Status (power derived from culturally and socially
defined position that person occupies in a group)
iii. Party (political power)
•
Power depends on one’s location in these three
structures*
6-17
WEBER: SOCIAL CLASS
AND LIFE CHANCES
• Gave primary emphasis in social stratification to
economic underpinnings
• Claimed there was larger variety of class
positions than found in Marx’s theory
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
• Emphasized life chances:
Opportunities (or lack thereof) for higher standard
of living and a better quality of life that are
available to members of a given class*
6-18
DAVIS AND MOORE:
FUNCTIONAL THEORY OF
STRATIFICATION
• Inequality exists in all societies Must be
necessary
• All societies have occupational roles that need to be
filled, with some roles requiring more training than
others (e.g., the more important roles)
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
• Greater rewards (e.g., money, prestige) necessary
to encourage people to undertake extended training
and fill these important roles
• Social inequality is therefore necessary and
inevitable*
6-19
CRITICISMS OF DAVIS
AND MOORE
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
• Theory does not account for the following:
Huge income and wealth inequalities
Gender differences in income even if same type
of work undertaken
Inherited wealth
Arbitrariness of denoting most important roles
(e.g., movie stars, nurses, daycare workers)
• Criticized as justification for large inequalities*
6-20
LENSKI: TECHNOLOGY AND
STRATIFICATION SYSTEMS
• Society’s technological base largely determines
degree of inequality within it
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
• Owners of means of production need to rely on
well-educated managerial and technical workers
Reliance gives rise to workers’ demands for
greater portion of the growing wealth in industrial
society
Employers give in to demands because they
cannot produce wealth without these workers
• Envisioned movement towards more equal
distribution of wealth*
6-21
WRIGHT’S NEO-MARXIST
THEORY OF CLASS
• Recognized that as industrial capitalism
matured, the middle class had grown and
become more diverse
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
• Emphasized “contradictory class
locations”:
An occupational grouping with divided
loyalties
• Also identified three classes of owners
and nine classes of wage labourers*
6-22
ERIC OLIN WRIGHT’S TYPOLOGY OF CLASS
LOCATION IN CAPITALIST SOCIETY
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
6-23
WRIGHT’S NEO-MARXIST
THEORY OF CLASS
• Argued exploitation of one class by
another can occur through:
Control of property or means of production
(as Marx insisted)
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
Ownership of skill or credential assets,
and
Control of high positions within
organizations*
6-24
PARKIN’S NEOWEBERIAN APPROACH
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
•
Developed Weber’s concept of social closure:
Methods used by more powerful groups to
maintain their unequal access to status and
resources, and to exclude others from such
access
•
i.
Two types of closure strategies:
Exclusion: Organized effort of the privileged, more
powerful groups to maintain their advantaged
position (e.g., lawyers, members of trade unions)
Usurpation: Effort of excluded groups to gain
advantages and power at expense of more
powerful groups (e.g., women)*
ii.
6-25
OCCUPATIONS, SOCIAL CLASS,
AND INEQUALITY IN CANADA
• Most prominent occupational shift over 20th century
was decline in agricultural occupations
• Also decline (albeit less) in other natural resourcebased occupations (e.g., forestry, fishing, mining)
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
• Increase in white-collar occupations (e.g.,
managerial, professional, clerical [office jobs], sales,
and service categories)
Have come to greatly outnumber blue-collar
occupations (e.g., manufacturing, construction,
transportation, and resource-based operations)*
6-26
OCCUPATIONS, SOCIAL
CLASS, AND INEQUALITY
IN CANADA
• Increase in proportion of occupations requiring
higher education
• Rise in average incomes (until early 1980s)
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
• Occupational shifts suggest:
Greater class diversity, not polarization of classes
Rising standard of living for Canadian workers,
not increasing poverty and exploitation*
6-27
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
OCCUPATIONAL
DISTRIBUTION
OF LABOUR
FORCE
PARTICIPANTS,*
CANADA, 1911,
1951, 2006
6-28
OCCUPATIONS, SOCIAL
CLASS, AND INEQUALITY IN
CANADA
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
• Gender-based labour market stratification has
continued:
Since middle of last century, proportion of women in
labour force has risen
But mostly in low-paid, low status “pink-collar”
sector (clerical, sales, and service occupations)
•
Large class of paid workers differentiated by:
Decision-making authority
Income status
Occupational power*
6-29
OCCUPATIONS, SOCIAL
CLASS, AND INEQUALITY IN
CANADA
• Dramatic decrease in proportion of self-employed
Canadians over past century
• Increase in unemployment
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
• Part-time and temporary work more common
• Income growth has stopped
• Increase in income and wealth inequality*
6-30
OCCUPATIONAL
MOBILITY AND STATUS
ATTAINMENT
• Occupational mobility: Moving up and down
occupational and income ladders
• Intragenerational occupational mobility: Mobility
within an individual’s lifetime
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
• Intergenerational occupational mobility: Process
of reaching occupation location higher or lower
than location held by parents
• Occupational status attainment: Main determinant
of status of a person’s current job is status of first
job (dependent on educational attainment)*
6-31
OCCUPATIONAL
MOBILITY IN CANADA
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
•
Globally, one of highest rates of upward mobility
•
More upward than downward intergenerational
mobility
•
Relatively open stratification system (especially
during 1970s and 1980s)
•
Yet intergenerational transfer of advantage
persists*
6-32
THE DISTRIBUTION OF
WEALTH IN CANADA
• Limited number of people continue to own or
control very large portion of wealth
• Concentration of ownership and wealth inequality
continue to increase:
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
Wealthiest 10% of families holds almost half of all
wealth in Canada
CEO’s multimillion dollar compensation packages
versus 11% of Canadian families with no net
worth*
6-33
INCOME DISTRIBUTION: HIGHPAYING AND LOW-PAYING
OCCUPATIONS
• Upper middle class: Those with well-paid managerial
and professional occupations (e.g., lawyers, dentists)
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
• Lower working class: Retail workers and those
employed in service occupations (e.g., childcare and
home support services)
• Gender differences hidden in occupational earning
patterns:
Females earn less than males in all occupations but
earnings ratio varies considerably by occupation*
6-34
AVERAGE EARNINGS IN SIX OCCUPATIONS
MOST COMMONLY HELD BY 15- TO 24-YEAROLDS WITH A UNIVERSITY DEGREE/
DIPLOMA AND WORKING FULL-TIME, FULL
YEAR BY SEX, CANADA, 2006
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
6-35
INCOME INEQUALITY
• Since mid-20th century, little change in distribution
of total income across households
• But increase in income inequality
Decline in share of total income received by the
three middle quintiles
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
• Immigrants significantly overrepresented among
Canada’s working poor despite higher education
and training
• Since 1990, average family income increased by
1%, versus 40% increase in average family debt*
6-36
THE POOR: DEFINING AND
MEASURING POVERTY
• Various ways of defining poverty:
Absolute poverty: Those with so little income that
survival is difficult
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
Relative poverty: Those with significantly less
income than others in their society
• Canada’s low-income cut-off (LICO) or poverty
line:
Those who spend more than 55% of gross
income on basic necessities*
6-37
WHO ARE THE POOR?
• Proportion of poor Canadians in 2001: 14.4%
• Only minority unemployed or out of labour force
• Working poor (those employed in low wage jobs)
make up large proportion of the poor
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
• Aboriginal Canadians among poorest citizens
• Poverty rate for single-parent families and seniors
(aged 65+) living alone: Both 42% in 2001
• Poverty not a static status: Sizable number move in
and out of poverty each year*
6-38
INCIDENCE OF LOW INCOME
FOR SELECTED FAMILY UNIT
TYPES, CANADA, 1980, 1990,
2004
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
6-39
SOCIAL ASSISTANCE FOR
THE POOR
• Misconception that level of social assistance
provides disincentive to work
• Ontario social assistance provides:
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
Income of only 34% of poverty line for single
employable adults
Income of only 56% of poverty line for single
parents
Income of only 59% of poverty line for those with
disabilities*
6-40
TOTAL WELFARE INCOME ($), AS
PERCENTAGE OF (PRETAX) POVERTY
LINE AND OF MEDIAN INCOME
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
6-41
MATERIAL INEQUALITY IN
CANADA: A SUMMARY
• Level of material inequality is relatively low compared
with many other countries and with a century ago
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
•
But have witnessed increases in:
Corporate concentration
Wealth inequality
Income inequality
Number of working poor
Unemployment rates (long-term trend)
Part-time and temporary employment
Inequality in earnings (re: polarization in hours
worked)*
6-42
MATERIAL INEQUALITY IN
CANADA: A SUMMARY
• Reduction in employment opportunities
• More competitive economic environment (due to
globalization)
• Routine layoffs and downsizing
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
• Replacement of full-time permanent jobs with parttime and temporary positions
• Weakened labour movement
• Decrease in state efforts to reduce material
inequalities*
6-43
CONSEQUENCES OF
MATERIAL INEQUALITY
• Position in class structure has effect on belief
systems, behaviours, voting patterns, lifestyles,
and, most importantly, life chances (e.g., health,
longevity, educational attainment, criminality)
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
• Increasing inequality may mean more social
unrest among the poor
But more opposition today from better-organized,
better-funded middle class*
6-44
RESPONDING TO
INEQUALITY
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
•
Two views:
1.
Inequality is inevitable and need not be addressed
(tends to be espoused by the well-off)
2.
Inequality is unjust and needs to be addressed
(tends to be espoused by the poor):
i.
Socialist response: Overthrow capitalism
ii.
Reformist response: Government redistribution of
wealth to the poor (e.g., through pensions,
minimum-wage legislation, unemployment
insurance, etc.)*
6-45
RESPONDING TO
INEQUALITY: CANADA’S
RESPONSE?
• Canada’s “liberal” welfare policies espouse faith in
power of free market to produce wealth and
improve condition of poor (despite little evidence
of success)
Copyright © 2011 by Nelson Education Ltd
Priority today given to deficit-reducing initiatives
rather than reduction of material inequality
• Responding to inequality effectively will require
willingness on part of many to accept less so that
others can have more**
6-46