Transcript Family Law Act - Bull, Housser & Tupper

British Columbia’s new Family Law Act
Carmen S. Thériault, Q.C.
and Emma McArthur
BULL HOUSSER CPD SEMINAR
November 19, 2013
Former Family Relations Act Regime
• Rights of married and common law spouses are
different
• Division of “family purpose assets” available only to
legally married spouses or those spouses who have
opted in under s. 120.1 of the Act
• Non family purpose assets(including business
assets) are excluded in the absence of direct/indirect
contribution by non-owning spouse
• Family assets could be reapportioned if the court
feels a 50/50 division was unfair
2
Highlights of B.C.’s new Family Law
Act
• Property rights for common law spouses
• All property is divisible, regardless of use by one
or both spouses, unless it is “excluded” property
• Shared liability for “family debt”
• Enforceability of marriage and cohabitation
agreements appears to have been strengthened
3
1. Definition of “Spouse” - section 3
Spouses are persons who:
a) are legally married,
b) have lived in marriage like relationship for continuous
period of at least 2 years, or
c) have lived in marriage-like relationship [no duration
specified] if they have a child – but (c) is only relevant for
spousal support purposes
4
2. Family Property that will be divided:
a) all property that either spouse owns or has a
beneficial interest in on the day they separate
that does not qualify as “excluded property”, and
b) property acquired after the date of separation
that is derived from the family property referred
to above.
5
Continued. . .
Family property includes among other things: - s.
84(a)
a) a share or an interest in a corporation
b) an interest in a partnership, an association, an
organization, a business or a venture
c) the amount by which the value of excluded
property has increased since the later of the
date the relationship began or the excluded
property was acquired
6
Excluded property includes:
a) property owned by a spouse before the
relationship began
b) gifts and inheritances
c) settlement and damage awards from tort claims
– except awards meant to compensate both
spouses or to replace wages
d) non-property related insurance proceeds
7
Continued...
e)
property previously referred to that is held in trust for a
spouse
f)
property held in certain discretionary trusts – s. 85(1)(f)
trust
g)
property traceable back to excluded property
8
When is Excluded Property Divided?
a) If it increases in value during the relationship,
the increase is divided
b) If family property/debt located out of BC can’t
practically be divided, the court may make an
order requiring the division of excluded property
9
Continued...
c) If it would be significantly unfair not to divide excluded
property on consideration of:
• the duration of the relationship, and
• a spouse’s direct contribution to the preservation,
improvement, operation or management of the excluded
property
10
When will a court order an unequal
division of family property?
• Pre-requisite for unequal division is significant unfairness
(under previous law it was simply “unfairness”)
• Factors to be considered by are listed in the FLA
• Court can also order unequal division of family debt
11
3. Triggering event and valuation
• Triggering event is the date of separation
• Valuation date is (1) the date an agreement is
signed or (2) the date of the hearing before the
court - unless the spouses agree otherwise or court
orders otherwise
12
4. Marriage and Cohabitation Agreements
• The provisions of the FLA are subject to the spouses’ agreement
otherwise
• Agreements may be set aside for reasons of procedural unfairness
or for substantive reasons
13
• Agreements may be set aside due to defects in the process of
making the agreement:
• failure to make proper disclosure,
• a spouse takes improper advantage of the other’s vulnerability,
ignorance, need,
• a spouse did not understand nature and consequences of
agreement, or
• other circumstances which would make all/part of a contract
voidable at common law
Continued. . .
Agreements may also be set aside if it would be
“significantly unfair” not to do so, having regard to:
• length of time that has passed since the agreement was
executed
• intentions of the parties to achieve certainty
• the degree to which the spouses relied upon the terms
of the agreement
15
Transition
The Family Relations Act continues to apply where:
• agreement made before the FLA comes into force – e.g
March 18, 2013 – unless spouses agree otherwise
• a proceeding respecting property division has already
been started under the FRA (with some exceptions)
16
7. Guardianship
Ways guardianship of a child can be obtained:
•
parents
•
court order
•
temporary guardianship
•
standby guardianship
•
testamentary guardianship
17
Continued...
Parents as Guardians:
• each parent of a child is a child’s guardian (s. 39)
• If a child’s guardian marries or enters into a marriagelike relationship, the new spouse does not become a
guardian of the child by reason only of the marriage or
relationship
18
Continued...
Guardians have parental responsibilities – s. 41 and 43
• modeled largely on s. 18 of Alberta’s Family Law Act
• reflects traditional role/authority of a parent
• must be exercised in the best interests of the child
19
Continued...
A Guardian is not:
• a trustee of a child’s property
• entitled to provide a valid discharge for receipt of
property on behalf of a child, subject to limited
exception
20
Continued...
Guardian is temporarily unable to exercise certain parental
responsibilities? – s. 43(2)
• the guardian may, in writing, authorize another person
to do so
• temporarily is not a defined term
21
Continued...
Appointment of Guardian in case of death – s. 53(1)
• in a Will or in the prescribed form – see Family Law Act
Regulation, BC Reg. 347/2012
• can now be exercised by parent and non-parent guardians
22
Continued...
Appointment of Standby Guardian – s. 55
• where there is only one guardian and he/she faces
terminal illness or permanent mental incapacity
• can appoint a person to become a guardian with the
appointing guardian when the conditions in the
appointment are met
23
British Columbia’s new Family Law Act:
Family Law and Estate Planning Implications
Carmen S. Thériault, Q.C.
and Emma McArthur
BULL HOUSSER CPD SEMINAR
November 19, 2013