Presentation (MS PowerPoint 2MB)

Download Report

Transcript Presentation (MS PowerPoint 2MB)

Harnessing ICT-based Tool for Improving the Collaborative Health Planning Debate; the

Case of Logan- Beaudesert, Australia

Presenters: * Ori Gudes – Griffith University & QUT The study is Supervised by : Tan Yigitcanlar, Elizabeth Kendall and Virendra Pathak

1

Geospatial Revolution clip

 Geospatial Revolution clip  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZdQjc30YPOk&feature=channel 2

Aims of the Study

 To examine the role of decision support systems as a mechanism to facilitate collaborative health decision-making  To develop a potential information management framework to underpin a health decision support system  To generate a participatory process to create an online tool for health planners using geographic information systems (GIS)  To measure and understand the impact and effectiveness of decision support systems on health decision-makers / health planners 3

Problems to address

  

Lack of an effective information in health planning Lack of collaboration in decision-making practice Lack of evidence in decision-making processes

4

Decision Support Systems

Decision support systems (DSS) are set of solution mechanisms that help all forms of decision makers to assess complex decision-making processes and to solve problems faced by the help of ICT tools (Shim et al., 2002).

DSS aims to

 Improve efficiency stakeholders of decisions  Optimise their overall performance  Minimise judgemental biases Turban, 1990 made by

Health Decision Support System Evidence-based Policy Public Participation Knowledge Sharing

5

How our data collection efforts have been grounded?

  

Fundamental / macro level

 most difficult to influence  greatest benefits achieved

Intermediate / meso level

 more easily influenced

Proximate / micro level

    level where we usually work least effective necessary for planning have been given greater scientific attention in recent years 

Individual level

 targeting disease   not most successful influence the individual habitués.

This framework summarises the different levels of factors that impact upon health and, therefore, should be considered in health planning initiatives.

Health assessment framework

Schulz and Northridge (2004) 6

Fundamental Macro Level Public Housing Public Housing Demographic Population Projected population Mortality rate Indigenous Multicultural (Clustered Nationalities) Nationalities Mortality Socio Economic SEIFA Index Unemployment Internet access Education Public Housing ’ s rate Income average and financial resources Businesses by Industry Division Has need for assistance with core activities Crime Crime rate (based on the Australian Standard Offence Classification) Boundaries Statistical Local Area Postcode Suburb Environmental Biodiversity and Contaminated land Environmental hazards Terrain Aerial images (Orthophoto) Topography (DEM) Contour Bus stations Bus routes Railway Stations Railway routes

Our Dataset

Proximate Micro Level Health Behaviours and Social Support Physical activity Social support Dietary practice (BMI Index) Health facilities Pharmacies Aged care Breast Screen Child Health (paediatric) Medical Services Mental health Oral health Public hospitals Private hospitals GP ’ s Medicare Education Facilities Child community Services Higher education Libraries Schools Special education State Pre School Youth clubs Play groups Universities / TAFE Community facilities Community centres Community facilities Community Welfare Employment services Religious institutions Services clubs Social clubs Sporting clubs Youth clubs Schools, State, Non-state schools Centre link offices Recreation Parks City swimming pools Sporting facilities Cycling paths Emergency Police Fire Fire Ambulance Other Shopping centres Non profit organisations Fast food outlets Roads Individual Outcome Level Health Outcomes Child health data Obesity Cancer Mental health Respiratory health (Asthma) Cardio-vascular Diabetes Communicable disease Avoidable admissions Hospital admissions (the following diseases: Depression, Renal, Diabetes, Respiratory) Well-Being Hope / despair Life satisfaction or life style Happiness and self fulfilment Disability Health status

Our Spatial Dataset

(derived from Schulz and Northridge 2004 ) 7

HDSS Data Sources

ABS Internet and public domain Others EPA Data Sources for The HDSS QLD Police Scenic Rim Regional Council Logan City Council Queensland Health

8

Why should we use DSS? Our Conceptual framework

How the HDSS will be used

?

Bringing together diverse datasets using a spatial methodology to empower stakeholders in planning for healthy communities

9

Pre DSS intervention survey

The quantitative data was collected using a 31-item survey based on several decision-making scales (Dean & Sharfman, 1993; Flood et al, 2000; Bennet et al, 2010; Parnell & Bell, 1994). The items measured the following dimensions of decision-making: Evidence-based decision-making; Perceived consensus; Participation in decision-making; Perceived satisfaction of decision-making; Perceived importance of decision-making Perceived effectiveness of decision-making; and Perceived equity of decision-making;

Where are we?

South East Queensland South of Brisbane City -------------- Population: 270,000 31 SLAs 1 in 4 smokers 13% high risk alcohol 66% overweight 11

LBHC structure

A collaborative arrangement between government and non government agencies, the private sector and community to develop and deliver health programs and services

Accessibility to hospitals based on travel time 13

Fast-food outlets and their proximity to schools 14

Hotpot analysis based on people who admitted to hospitals with diabetes * (Based on Logan-Beaudesert Hospitals data 2005-2007) 15

Accessibility to internet as key variable for future E-health initiatives and planning 16

Preliminary findings from the Pre DSS survey

• Low levels of satisfaction with the decision-making processes across the LBHC. • There was some diversity across the components of the LBHC Some groups within the LBHC were more satisfied than others (i.e., those who were over 40 years). There was also a tendency for LBHC board members, males, new members and veterans to be more satisfied with information and perceive higher levels of consensus, participation and evidence-based decision-making. • There was an overall sense that decisions were ineffective, presumably because they were not based on information or evidence.

Conclusion from the Pre DSS survey findings

• New members are enthusiastic, but become more critical of decision making over time and then eventually resolve this situation in some way – either by withdrawing or seeking other sources of information). • Age of members had an important influence on the way decision-making was perceived. It is possible that younger people could be more demanding in terms of their need for involvement in the decision-making processes, whereas veterans are likely to have access to more intrinsic sources of information based on years of experience in the region. As a result, they may be less demanding of the decision-making processes.

Overall discussion

In summary, our findings have shown that: There was considerable diversity in the way decision-making were perceived, this, in turn, may require different approaches to health planning across different groups. The findings have also highlighted the need for a comprehensive information framework and collaborative process to underpin planning for healthy cities, thus enabling health coalitions to make effective decisions that engage all stakeholders equitably.

The framework proposed in this paper would not only encourage planners to engage with evidence and information about the entire range of health determinants, but would also provide a platform for collaboration and shared engagement in the decision-making process.

Future Research

Unanswered questions: • How the suggested framework and method are actually applied in local communities • The impact of the HDSS on decision-making and its ability to facilitate collaborative-based health planning debate

These important research questions shall be addressed as we conduct the next phases in this ongoing project.

HDSS Where to from here, challenges and practicalities for Logan council?

Prototype development stage – phase 1

Dec 2010 Nov 2011

HDSS expanding usage to the whole public – phase 3

Nov 2012 Nov 2014

Phase 2 Dataset update (ABS) and HDSS expanding usage to the whole LBHC National level / collaboration with other bodies within QLD and West Australia or CRC-SI

“”Maps can show you where you are. But a good map can also show you where you want to go, and what needs to happen so that you can get there”

(http://www.mappingforchange.org.uk/, 2009)

22

`