Australian foreign policy objectives

Download Report

Transcript Australian foreign policy objectives

Australian Foreign
Policy –
National interests and
Objectives
Ron Anderson
SEV Lecture
Aug 6 2010
This lecture will focus on
1. Historical Background – the Basic
transition in AFP
2. Objectives of AFP (national interests)
3. Basic Bipartisanship
4. Some areas of tension within these
objectives
Study Design: National Politics:
Key Knowledge
Australian foreign policy objectives;
role of Minister for Foreign Affairs, Minister for Trade,
Prime Minister, cabinet, the parliament, the Department
of Foreign Affairs and Trade, foreign aid, overseas
delegations including embassies and consulates;
differences between the making of domestic policy and
foreign policy;
impact on Australian foreign policy of Australia’s near
neighbours, including relations with regional leaders;
impact on Australian foreign policy of factors such as
domestic politics, human rights, refugees,
international opinion, international conflict, trade and
economic blocs.
Study Design: National Politics
Key Skills - the ability to
define and use key concepts relating to
foreign policy;
explain and synthesise foreign policy
objectives;
analyse and compare policy processes;
evaluate challenges to foreign policy;
access, interpret and draw conclusions
from information gathered from print and
electronic sources.
Study Design: International Studies
Key knowledge
• the historical background to AFP;
• the issue of security and alliance relationships;
• the economic dimension of foreign policy;
• the role of internationalism in AFP;
• the debate about national interest;
• regional relationships;
• recent changes in orientation & goals of AFP
Key skills
• analyse ideas and debates about national interest in AFP
• recognise tensions that have developed in AFP
• analyse the relative importance of factors that have contributed
to the development of AFP;
• define key terms and use relevant concepts.
Main Themes in AFPin the past there has been a strong
1.Threat mentality (note change from past
exaggerated threat perception to a more rational
threat perception)
2. Vulnerability assumptions- feelings among A
that we are at risk
3. Regional suspicion –we’re suspicious of the
region; the region is suspicious of Australia.
4. Dependence assumptions – need for a strong
and powerful alliance with a major western
power
Basic Transition since the ’70s –
FROM
TO
Traditional foreign policy
* Exaggerated threat mentality vulnerability
* cultural and racial xenophobia
* regional fears & vulnerability
* Dependence
Policies
* strong ties to Europe
* US alliance
* isolation in Asia
* regional security through
reliance on Western power
* forward defence
* economic ties with Europe
New foreign policy
* Rational threat mentality
No direct immediate threat
* Regional independence
* Aust. can operate in the
region by itself
* greater independence
Policies
* engagement with Asia
* defence self reliance
* regional independence
assertion of power in Pacific
* US alliance more global
* regional trade
* human rights etc
Re this Transition
Basic acceptance by both parties of its main elements:
rational threat perception
engagement in Asia
still use for the US alliance
In effect
(i) general elite bipartisanship – both major parties share
these modern views
(ii) some popular disensus – Hansonsism and One
Nation?
A small remnant of the population – tied to old atavistic
foreign policy – we’re vulnerable
1. Direct Security
Basic elements - mainland security; border protection;
control of key strategic zones
Policies & aspects
- defence self reliance - adequate defence forces for
detection, deterrence and direct mainland defence;
- Strategic surveillance – Cocos and Christmas Islands –
for Indian Ocean surveillance
- Strong intelligence networks – advance knowledge of
‘threats’
- maintain stability in key strategic zones –’Island Screen’
modern technological military equipment
- Deterrence through collective security pacts – ANZUS
- Strong regional diplomatic ties to detect or prevent
‘problems – terrorists, ‘asylum seekers’
2. Regional Stability & Security
Basic Elements
- stability in SW Pacific; South East Asia; Asia generally
Policies and Aspects:
- military capability intervene without sacrificing direct defence –
naval power projection - Fiji; Solomons etc
- Strong influence (aid & diplomacy) on vulnerable micro states
in SW Pacific, and PNG – significant aid to PNG;
- control of Pacific Forum;
- Strong and positive regional ties with neighbours – Indonesia
SEA nations.
- Sufficient force projection to deter, counter-attack any
potential regional attack
- ‘Howard Doctrine’ – Australia to act to provide regional
stability as ‘deputy’ to the US
3. Global Stability & Security
Basic Elements: maintain peaceful core global
relationships esp. with core allies
Policies & Aspects:
- US alliance A. tied to US global positions
(i) core socio-cultural assumptions – democracy etc.
(ii) defence ties - equipment, intelligence, training
(iii) expectation of ANZUS - Aust. defence if required
- ‘Traditional’ support for US wars - Korea Vietnam
wars; Gulf war 1 1990; Iraq; Afghanistan
- Strengthened under Howard govt.: invocation of
ANZUS after Sept. 11; War on Terror
- anti- weapons of mass destruction– Nuclear non
proliferation treaty (NNPT) ban on atmospheric
testing etc: active in Chemical Weapons Treaty
4. Economic Devel. & Prosperity
1. A’s wealth depends on exports and commodity prices
2. Therefore reliance on
(i) exports - from Farm to Quarry.
- importance of export prices and access
(ii) energy sources – esp. oil directly & to trading partners
(iii) trade routes
2. Importance of neo-liberalist views (since early ’80s under
Hawke) – deregulation, and integration into global environment
(acceptance of Globalisation)
3. Preference for free markets- few subsidies, tariffs and quotas
4. support for ‘Cairns group’ (1988), APEC, GATT (since 1947)
World Trade Organisation
- bilateral free trade agreements
5. Internal implications – internal economic policies should follow
– cut tariffs and subsidies – this has encouraged (i)
unemployment (ii) de-industrialisation and (iii) movement of
5. ‘Internationalism’
Basic Elements:
Being, and being seen to be, Good International Citizens
(Gareth Evans) with regard to
terrorism; narcotics;
international crime; AIDS;
refugees,
slavery;
piracy,
climate change,
UN
human rights and democracy;
WMD
Policies & Aspects:
- international agreements over – narcotics, AIDs,
refugees, international crime, the environment, weapons
of mass destruction; piracy, slavery etc
- Support for the UN and other multilateral international
organisations
- Advocacy of democracy, individualism and human rights
General elite bipartisanship
Both major parties agree about the main
national interests/objectives
But there are differences
(i) within each party
(ii) of emphasis between parties
‘Popular’ (outside the elite)
Dissensus
Some exceptions to bipartisanship:
(a) left idealists – higher priority on
‘idealism’ – internationalism less emphasis
on pragmatic realities
(b) right wing xenophobes – Hanson etc –
emphasis is on preserving older national
identity (1950s racism and xenophobia –
anti-multiculturalism and pro White
Australia)
Tensions and Debates over US
alliance 1
1. US alliance – loss of sovereignty
2. US alliance – Nature of ANZUS and
defence guarantee
3. Cost and benefits of the US alliance
4. US alliance conflict with regionalism?
5. US alliance and internationalism – loss of
human rights in WOT
Security and Alliance Relationships
– (1)
Problem of defining the US alliance – is it just ANZUS?
Does ANZUS exist? (or is it ‘AUS’)
Or more than a simple treaty relationship
2. But differences:
ALP is more critical of aspects –
loss of sovereignty;
too locked into the US global security position;
denies internationalist positions
Lib/National – believe in the totality of the whole alliance
– have to accept it all; can’t pick and choose
1.
Security and Alliance
Relationships – (2)
3. Difference is mainly one of priority
ALP – US alliance for direct defence; more
reliance on independence and different regional
positions
Lib/National – more inclined to threat perceptions
and hence support alliance in total
4. US alliance is a delicate balance of cost –
benefits (see accompanying notes)
5. Note the ‘Howard Doctrine’ – a new form of A’s
alignment with the US (see notes)
Debates about alliance: US alliance
(3)
Is it slavish following of US policy as a
puppet Reason?- get defence guarantee
(Does ANZUS guarantee A’s defence? No!)
OR
Similarity of viewpoints – coincidence of
objectives?
Economic development and other
FP aspects
Problem of Consistency between
(i) economic and security/alliance interests
US alliance and missile defence Pine Gap,
containment of China, support for Taiwan,
versus trade with China
(ii) Economic and human rights interests
(internationalism)
Trade with China and human rights (prodemocracy, capital punishment, Tibet, Uighers
leader visit)
Debates over regionalism (regional
involvement)
Extent of regionalism
engagement to the point of engulfment?
(Howard’s criticism of Keating – obsession
with region, to the detriment of broader
issues)
or simply limited pragmatic engagement for
mutual problems – terrorism, Asylum
seekers (Howard and Rudd/Gillard)