Transcript Case Management Conference

“It’s Not Just For
C. difficile Anymore”
Prof Thomas J. Borody
MD, PhD, FRACP, FACP, FACG, AGAF
Centre for Digestive Diseases
Sydney, Australia
August , 2014
Disclosure statement
TJ Borody makes the following disclosures:
 RedHill Biopharma: scientific advisory board
(honorary)
 Salix Pharmaceuticals: research grant
 CIPAC Consultant (honorary)
 GSK, Salix Pharmaceuticals, Giaconda Pty Ltd:
stock
 Patents: in various fields, including FMT
 Pecuniary interest in Centre for Digestive
Diseases, where FMT is a treatment option
Centre for Digestive Diseases
 Established October 1984
 Free standing GI endoscopic Clinic
 6 Gastroenterologists and a staff of 47
 FMT since 1998; > 4500 procedures
 No restrictions on use in CDI nor non – CDI
indications
 Restriction on “supply”
3
4
FMT Outside Relapsing CDI-1
 FDA Guidance : FMT to treat C. difficile not
responding to standard therapies
• CEBER July 2013
A. FMT in CDI and IBD
- Common (Issa et al I B Dis 2008)
- Eradicates 90% (Borody UEGJ 2013)
- Prolongs remission in minority
- Rarely dramatic reversal of IBD
5
FMT IBD :CD
CASE 2
 47 y male, 1 yr Hx severe CD (previous 3 yr Hx UC)
 Diarrhea 20-25/day, bleeding, cramping, fatigue – possible
surgery candidate, toxin-positive CDI
 CRP=68.5*, Hb=114*
 35mg prednisone, 20mg/wk MTX
 Symptoms improved somewhat
on pre-FMT vancomycin regime
 Posterior fissures, very severe
distal inflammation with
pseudopolyps, ulcers and
scarring throughout bowel
Sigmoid colon, fully-prepped bowel
FMT IBD :CD
 Two-day infusion: transcolonoscopic + next day enema
 CDI eradicated.
At 13 mo F/U:
 1-2 formed stools/day. No bleeding, no mucus, no
urgency
 CRP=6, Hb=160
 Able to return to work, 20kg
weight gain
 No medication 1 year
 Best result
Sigmoid colon, unprepped bowel
FMT Outside Relapsing CDI-2
B. FMT in Non R-CDI
- With significant co-morbidities
- Immunosuppressed / transplants (Kelly et al 2014
AmJG)
- Pregnancy - ?
- With non-significant co-morbidities
- First time CDI – 2 infusions ~ 100%
- D-IBS + CDI –  Diarrhoea – occasional
cure
- C-IBS + CDI – Rare cure with 1-2 FMT
Eradication still >90%
8
Disorders associated with altered
intestinal microbiome and/or
responded to FMT-1
GI
• Clostridium difficile infection (CDI)
• IBD – UC and Crohn’s*
• Sclerosing cholangitis*
• IBS
• Recurrent diverticulitis*
• Halitosis
9
Disorders associated with altered
intestinal microbiome and/or
responded to FMT-2
Non GI
• Arthritis
• Autoimmune – ITP*
• Autism
• Chronic Fatigue Syndrome
• Diabetes mellitus and
insulin resistance
• Acne vulgaris
• Mood disorders
• Metabolic syndrome
• Multiple sclerosis*
• Parkinson’s disease
Modified : Brandt et al 2013 Am J
Gastro
10
FMT: Inflammatory Bowel Disease
 1988: Our first case (indeterminate colitis): 2 infusions. Remains






cured > 25 years (Borody et al 1989)
1989, Bennet et al: self-treated with FMT, clinical and histological
normality. (Bennet et al Lancet 1989)
2003: 6 cases, remain ‘cured’ 1-15 years (Borody et al 2003)
2011: repeated enema infusions – key to IBD
2012: Systematic review. Majority of patients experience symptom
improvement (19/25), disease remission (15/24) and cessation of
medication (13/17) (Anderson et al, 2012)
2012: 62 cases UC – Prolonged histological ‘remission’ (Borody et al
2012)
Reports of isolated cases of dramatic clinical and histological
improvement:
- Kao et al, 2014 ; Gordon et al, 2014 ; Zhang et al, 2013
Retrospective Review – FMT in UC
 62 UC patients – No CDI
 Simple Clinical Colitis Activity Index (Walmsley)
 Reduction >4 points – Marked improvement
2-4 points – moderate
0 points – no improvement
• 17/62 (27%) – Marked improvement
• 26/62 (42%) – Moderate
• 16/62 (26%) – No improvement
• 3/62 (5%)
– Worsened
• 17 with marked improvement
• Clinically well, formed stool
• Endoscopically normal
• Histologically normal
• “Remission” = 1-24 years
12
Changes by Age Group
16
14
13
13
14
Worsening of
Symptoms
12
10
10
No Improvement
8
7
Moderate Improvement
6
4
2
3
1
2
Significant
Improvement
0
Group A (18 - 35 years) Group B (36 - 80 years)
13
Retrospective Review – FMT in UC
 62 UC patients – No CDI
 Simple Clinical Colitis Activity Index (Walmsley)
 Reduction >4 points – Marked improvement
2-4 points – moderate
0 points – no improvement
• 17/62 (27%) – Marked improvement
• 26/62 (42%) – Moderate
• 16/62 (26%) – No improvement
• 3/62 (5%) – Worsened
• 17 with marked improvement
• Clinically well formed stool
• Endoscopically normal
• Histologically normal
• “Remission” = 1-24 years
14
FMT for IBD: UC
Case 1:
 21 y; 10 yr Hx of severe UC failing Rx (steroids, anti-TNFs)
 Commenced FMT April 2010: immediate symptom
improvement, lowered CRP approx 1 month after starting
enemas
 Completed 26 FMT enemas
Pre-FMT
Post-FMT
15
FMT for IBD: UC
Case 2
 33 y M. 8 wk abdominal pain, diarrhoea, mucus + blood.
First diagnosis of UC
 Rx: Standard anti-inflammatory : frequent relapses.
Before FMT pre-treated with ciprofloxacin,
metronidazole, mesalazine and prednisone.
 FMT via trans-colonoscopic infusion then daily, twiceweekly, weekly, FMT infusions. After 80 FMT he was recolonoscoped on 14/9/12.
 He was passing normal stool once per day and was off all
drugs then for 7 months and has continued well
16
Before
After
Rectum
Above: Rectum (L), Rectum (R)
Sigmoid colon
Sigmoid colon
Above: Sigmoid colon (L), Terminal
ileum (R)
17
FMT for IBD: UC
Case 3
 38y M. Distal colitis proximal pseudopolyps - sclerosing
cholangitis with elevated LFT’s. C. difficile negative
 1st infusion transcolonoscopic, followed by daily infusions,
then three per week and reducing. 2nd colonoscopy
3/10/2012 after ~ 100 FMT infusions. Once per week for
now. Stools formed for a couple of days after infusion and
then they became unformed.
 Next colonoscopy 6/2/2013. FMT now weekly or second
weekly. Regained weight. No blood, no mucus and formed
stools. Note: Serum ALP fell from 338 to 94 - other liver
functions normal.
 Unprepared colonoscopy showed no inflammation.
18
Before
After
Sigmoid colon
Sigmoid colon, showing
mucus, blood
Sigmoid colon, showing
pseudopolyps
Transverse colon
Transverse colon
Hepatic flexure
Hepatic flexure
Ascending colon
Caecum, infusing FMT
19
FMT for IBD: UC
Case 4
 53y M, severe distal colitis on immune-suppressants,
5ASA antibiotics facing surgery. Chose recurrent FMT, C.
difficile toxin positive found
 9/12/2011 - first FMT. Severe distal inflammation. For CDI
- had single trans-colonoscopic FMT followed by enema. 7
weeks later he felt “fantastic”. No urgency, no blood, one
motion per day.
 10/1/2013 – colonoscopy; tubular adenoma removed but
mucosa normal. Histology - small numbers of neutrophils
within laminar propria - focal mild cryptitis The patient
was passing normal formed stools daily. Remains clinically
well currently
20
FMT for PROCTITIS: UC
Case 5
 57y F. Nine y history of refractory proctitis (failed 5-ASA , steroids,
antibiotics, probiotics, immunosuppressants and acetarsol).
 FMT commenced Dec 2007 (69 sessions of infusions)
 10 days into FMT immediate clinical response diarrhoea ceased
Colonoscopy at 3y and 5y showed no visible or histological
inflammation. Now asymptomatic >5y years + off all meds without
relapse
Rectum - Prior FMT
Rectum - Post FMT
21
Before
Top: Rectum. Below: sigmoid colon
After
Top: Rectum showing adenomatous polyp.
22
Below: sigmoid colon
FMT for IBD: CD
Case 1:
 14 y M: Severe Crohn’s ileitis, C. difficile positivity on
Prednisone and Imuran. Marked symptoms – poorly
controlled.
 Terminal ileitis - 17/1/2012, FMT 17/4/2012. Instead of doing
2 infusions mother continued home infusions with marked
improvement. Total of 60 infusions. No antibiotics. Able to
stop Imuran. Acne healed by 7 days. Stools: 1-2 formed per
day with all inflammatory parameters normal.
 15/11/2012 – Colonoscopy; terminal ileum was totally normal
,no aphthoid erosions, no cobblestoning, no inflammation.
Donor was 15 year old cousin. Normal colonocopy March 2014
23
Before
After
Terminal ileum
Terminal ileum
Terminal ileum:
erosions
Terminal ileum
Terminal ileum
Terminal ileum:
no visible
inflammation at
all
24
CDI
IBD
• No. of infusions:
•SINGLE+
• No. of infusions:
•MULTIPLE INFUSIONS
•Symptom Reversal
•Rapid
Cure
•Remission
• >90%
•Symptom Reversal
•Slow then rapid REVERSAL
•Remission
• > 80%
•Possibility of Cure:
•CURE > 95%
VS
•Possibility of Cure:
•Real Possibility: 10-15%
•Measure of Success :
•Negative Stool for CDI
•No symptoms
•Measure of Success :
•Normal histology
•No Symptoms
•Published Evidence
•Large volume of small case
reports > 1000 patients
•Published Evidence
•Case reports [n=?12]
25
Experience in IBS
 First reported by us in 1989 in 55 patients – most IBS
 @ CDD - most common indication is D-IBS
 Constipation-IBS more difficult to reverse – requires
repeated bowel cleaning and enema infusions
 Several ‘chronic nausea’ patients treated
 Several ‘abdominal pain’ only also treated
Borody et al 1989; MJA 150: 604
 Refractory D-IBS in 13 patients – 70% Improved
Pinn et al 2013; Am J Gast 108:S563
26
27
Use of FMT in Neurological
conditions
 FMT in three atypical MS patients at CDD.
 FMT found to reverse MS symptoms in 3/6
cases resulting in regaining lower motor skills
and urinary function and these patients
remained asymptomatic after receiving FMT –
F/U up to 17 y
28
29
Future of FMT
 Initial use of ‘frozen’ microbiota preparation
 Development and use of freeze-dried ‘enteric-coated’
microbiota capsules
 Expansion of use to growing number of applications
including – IBD, IBS, Diverticulitis; Acne; Halitosis;
Anorexia Nervosa; Metabolic Syndrome; Autism; Other
Neurologic indications; Autoimmune diseases;
?Prevention of Ca colon; Others
 Post-Antibiotic microbiota restoration
30
CONCLUSIONS
 FMT in Relapsing CDI is becoming mainstream
 In IBD FMT shows promise but need for repeated infusions is




a barrier
Many unanswered questions in IBD – e.g. treat actively using
FMT inflamed mucosa or heal first with conventional therapies
Future oral enteric coated FMT may be the ultimate therapy –
to maintain remission
Given the unprecedented sporadic IBD resolution with FMT
the mechanisms underlying IBD may need re-examination
Other areas are of interest and expose new mechanisms
31