Transcript What is Discourse Analysis? - the NCRM EPrints Repository

What is … Discourse Analysis?
Stephanie Taylor
The Open University
Discourse Analysis: starting points
• Research approach
• Language material (e.g. talk, written text)
• Evidence of social phenomena (beyond the individual)
2
Transcription
•
•
•
•
Talk -> written text
Transcription notation
Features e.g. repeated words, emphasis, intonation
Best known system by Gail Jefferson (often revised)
3
Places of residence: some possibilities for discourse analysis
• Address details
4
Places of residence: some possibilities for discourse analysis
• Address details
• Interview transcripts
5
Extract
INT: Right So what do you value most then about where you live
now?
P: Living here now um Safe I mean safety is actually Is important um
Although we’re living in London we’re quite here in particular we’re
very close to the river we’ve got lots of parks um It is built up but it’s
But it’s quite but there’s quite a bit of space around I think from that
point of view of living in [placename] area we’re very fortunate to
have lots of royal parks and we’re very close to the to the river as well
It’s close to central London so that should we want to use museums
and the theatres eccetera we can we can do that
Stephanie Taylor (2010) Narratives of Identity and Place London: Routledge.
6
Extract
INT: Right So what do you value most then about where you live
now?
P: Living here now um Safe I mean safety is actually Is important um
Although we’re living in London we’re quite here in particular we’re
very close to the river we’ve got lots of parks um It is built up but it’s
But it’s quite but there’s quite a bit of space around I think from that
point of view of living in [placename] area we’re very fortunate to
have lots of royal parks and we’re very close to the to the river as well
It’s close to central London so that should we want to use museums
and the theatres eccetera we can we can do that
Stephanie Taylor (2010) Narratives of Identity and Place London: Routledge.
7
Findings from the analysis
• Patterns in the data (‘discourses’, ‘interpretative
repertoires’, ‘discursive resources’)
e.g. references to possibilities, what you can do
8
Extract 2
INT: So what do you value most about where you’re living now can you
say that?
P: Um It’s a variety Of things that are available in that environment it’s
just everything is so easy to get to from there um And any kind of
resources that I might need to have are very easily obtainable there
either from going to shops or getting places to bring stuff to us or
finding information as well….[placename] is a is a whole huge market
area with kind of fashion and art and theatre and there’s so much
there you know that’s interesting that you can just kind of have a look
round It kind of feels as if you’re in touch with with what’s going on
there whereas other other places I’ve lived ‘ve felt a bit kind of samey
um High Street stuff and nothing kind of um I don’t know Not the
same kind of individuality…
9
Extract 2
INT: So what do you value most about where you’re living now can you
say that?
P: Um It’s a variety Of things that are available in that environment it’s
just everything is so easy to get to from there um And any kind of
resources that I might need to have are very easily obtainable there
either from going to shops or getting places to bring stuff to us or
finding information as well….[placename] is a is a whole huge market
area with kind of fashion and art and theatre and there’s so much
there you know that’s interesting that you can just kind of have a look
round It kind of feels as if you’re in touch with with what’s going on
there whereas other other places I’ve lived ‘ve felt a bit kind of samey
um High Street stuff and nothing kind of um I don’t know Not the
10
same kind of individuality…
Assumptions
•
•
•
•
Selective description (construction)
Shaped for purpose (function)
Speaking ‘as’ a certain person (positioning)
Partly rehearsed (version)
11
Talk is social:
(i) Shaped by shared resources
12
Talk is social:
(i) Shaped by shared resources
(ii) Situated, in context(s)
13
Talk is social:
(i) Shaped by shared resources
(ii) Situated, in context(s)
(iii) A social practice
14
Places of residence: possible material for discourse analysis
• Address details
• Interviews
• ‘Naturally occurring talk’ e.g. mediation session
15
Extract 2, mediation: initial interview
1 G: y’know it’s getting- it’s getting real serious this is (.)but the
2 lad keeps getting away with it (.) unfortunately (.) his mother hasn’t
3 got a bloke there (.) so she is talking in [front of the children
4 L: [she’s not living there half
5 the time is she=
6 G: =no she’s out at night and they are using it as a- a rendezvous for the
7 gang
[…]
8 G: that’s the whole top [and bottom of it
9 L: [it’s like the dustbin left out for a week (?) on
10 [the pavement
Elizabeth H. Stokoe (2003) ‘Mothers, Single Women and Sluts: Gender, Morality and Membership Categorization in
Neighbour Disputes’ Feminism & Psychology 2003 13(3) 317-344.
16
Findings
• Complaints about neighbours are gendered
• Categorization of women in moral terms
17
Premises
• Society is constituted through ongoing practices (made
and remade)
• Talk as a social practice
• Categorizations of women as a form of talk which
reinforces a gendered social order
18
What is discourse analysis?
(1) The study of well-established meanings or ideas around a topic
which shape how we can talk about it
19
What is discourse analysis?
(1) The study of well-established meanings or ideas around a topic
which shape how we can talk about it
e.g.
‘discourses of education’, ‘discourses of health and illness’,
‘discourses of place’
20
Possible problem:
• Too static?
21
What is discourse analysis?
(1) The study of well-established meanings or ideas around a topic
which shape how we can think and talk about it
(2) The study of how meanings are established, used, challenged
and changed (including in talk)
22
The study of how meanings are established, used,
challenged and changed (including in talk)
(i)
Over time (‘genealogical study’ Foucault)
23
The study of how meanings are established, used,
challenged and changed (including in talk)
(i)
Over time (‘genealogical study’ Foucault)
(ii)
In ordinary life (discourse practices)
24
Summary
• What is discourse analysis?
25
Two definitions:
(1) The study of well-established meanings or ideas around a topic
which shape how we can talk about it
(2) The study of how meanings are established, used, challenged
and changed (including in talk)
26
Why analyse discourse?
• To understand our social worlds and their complexity
• To understand the implications of certain meanings and world views
• To understand ourselves within our social worlds
27
What kinds of data?
• Language data (written, spoken - found, collected)
• Other kinds of evidence (images, behaviours, situations – found,
collected)
28
Criticisms of discourse analytic research:
• Deterministic? (But also about how meanings are used and
contested)
• Just words? (But discourse is material)
29
Why do discourse analysis?
• Varied possibilities
• Interesting
• About people and their social worlds
30
Dr Stephanie Taylor, The Open University
[email protected]
31