Transcript WECC 10-Year Plan general presentation
1
Bradley Nickell
Director of Transmission Planning
Planning for Renewables
Iowa State University WESEP-REU
June 12, 2012
2
About WECC
WECC’s mission is to promote and foster a reliable and efficient bulk electric system 3
Non-Planning Functions
• Compliance Monitoring and Enforcement • Standards Development • Reliability Coordination • Market-Operations interface • Operator training • WREGIS
Planning Functions
• Loads and Resources Assessments • Reliability studies • Transmission Expansion Planning
4
Regional Transmission Expansion Planning
History of Interconnection-wide planning in the West
• Planning cooperation among Western Interconnection entities o Create economic planning data sets o Perform interconnection-wide transmission expansion studies o Process consistent with applicable FERC Order 890 planning principles • Governed by the WECC Transmission Expansion Planning Policy Committee (TEPPC)
5
Agenda
• What are we planning for?
• Resource Planning • Modeling Renewable Resources • Telling the story
6
What are we planning for?
• Identification of future infrastructure needs to 1. Serve the expected load reliably 2. Meet public policy directives 3. Minimize cost and environmental impact • Transmission planning – identify future transmission capacity needs given a future set of loads and resources – It’s all about resource planning
2013 10- and 20-year Transmission Plans
Connecting the Dots
How might the Western Interconnection need to change to accommodate changes in the supply and demand for electric energy?
2032
• 10-year – understanding impacts of near-term decisions (bottoms-up) • 20-year – understanding drivers of potential energy futures (top-down) • The Plans tell the story of how they are connected
2012 2022
7
Understanding Impacts of decisions, not making determinations on what should be done
8
Transmission Expansion Planning Process
Study Requests Study Case Prioritization
• SPSG Scenarios • Study requests from all interested parties through the TEPPC Open Season • Initial prioritization • Review by stakeholders • Public comment • Create Study Program
Analysis
• Input by all interested parites through direct participation in Workgroups • Review by stakeholders
Create Transmission Plan
• Initial Plan and review in analysis process • Review stakeholders • Public comment • WECC Board approval
9
2022 TEPPC Common Case – Resource Assumptions
Resources Loads Transmission 2022 Common Case
10
Developing Resource Assumptions
1. Gather load assumptions 2. Identify state renewable energy requirements 3. Specify the renewable portfolio 4. Update conventional resources 5. Identify conventional resource retirements
6. Check the load and resource balance
WA: 15% x 2020* MT: 15% x 2015 RPS Policies www.dsireusa.org / May 2012 MN: 25% x 2025
(Xcel: 30% x 2020) VT: (1) RE meets any increase in retail sales x 2012; (2) 20% RE & CHP x 2017 ND: 10% x 2015
MI: 10% & 1,100 MW x 2015* OR : 25% x 2025 (large utilities )*
5% - 10% x 2025 (smaller utilities)
NV : 25% x 2025* CA: 33% x 2020
SD: 10% x 2015
CO: 30% by 2020 (IOUs) 10% by 2020 (co-ops & large munis)*
UT: 20% by 2025*
WI : Varies by utility;
~10% x 2015 statewide
IA: 105 MW NY: 29% x 2015 OH : 25% x 2025
†
IL: 25% x 2025 KS: 20% x 2020
IN: 10% x 2025 † WV: 25% x 2025* VA: 15% x 2025* †
MO: 15% x 2021 AZ: 15% x 2025
OK: 15% x 2015
NM: 20% x 2020 (IOUs) 10% x 2020 (co-ops) NC : 12.5% x 2021 (IOUs) 10% x 2018 (co-ops & munis) DC ME: 30% x 2000 New RE: 10% x 2017 NH: 23.8% x 2025 MA: 22.1% x 2020 New RE: 15% x 2020
(+1% annually thereafter)
RI: 16% x 2020 CT: 27% x 2020 PA: ~ 18% x 2021
†
NJ: 20.38% RE x 2021 + 5,316 GWh solar x 2026 MD: 20% x 2022 DE: 25% x 2026* DC: 20% x 2020 PR: 20% x 2035 TX: 5,880 MW x 2015 HI: 40% x 2030
Renewable portfolio standard Renewable portfolio goal Solar water heating eligible Minimum solar or customer-sited requirement Extra credit for solar or customer-sited renewables Includes non-renewable alternative resources
29 states an RPS
(8 states have goals)
+ DC and PR have
Overarching RPS Assumptions
• RPS percentages with a discrete jump (e.g., 15% to 20%) are pro rated using a linear path – Utah sets a 2025 target without interim requirements o Linear path sets target at 16% in 2022 • Set-asides are met – Distributed generation (AZ: 30% of RPS, CO: 3% of retail sales, NM: 3% of RPS) – Solar (NV: 1.32% of retail sales, NM: 4% of sales) • Credits are applied to applicable resources – CO grants 125% credit to instate generation – Multipliers (CO: community based projects, NV: solar PV, WA: distributed generation)
13
WECC 2022 Common Case Portfolio
Nuclear 7%
WECC 2022 Energy Generation by Type (2022 Common Case)
Combined Cycle 15% Combustion Turbine Cogeneration Other Biomass RPS 1% Geothermal 4% Small Hydro RPS 1% Solar 3% Renewables 17% Steam - Coal 26% Wind 8% Conventional Hydro 24%
14
Production Cost Modeling
• WECC’s studies are run using Promod, which is a production costing model (PCM) for projecting future system operating costs • WECC inputs into the PCM a transmission network, using a WECC power flow base case, and a single resource scenario • the PCM uses these model inputs to perform a security constrained economic dispatch of the WECC-wide system for each of 8,760 hours in the year
Production Cost Modeling
16 • PCM uses the following inputs to perform a security constrained economic dispatch of the WECC-wide system for each hour of the year: o Generator Unit Characteristics: unit types, heat rates, fuel types, forced outage rates, minimum downtimes, etc.
o Load Characteristics: chronological load shapes, etc.
o Transmission Network Characteristics: network topology, branch/transformer impedances, flow limits, etc. o System Operating Requirements: operating reserve requirements, etc.
17
PCM Modeling Inputs for Variable (Wind and Solar) Generation
• Wind/solar are fixed shape (non-dispatchable) resources – NREL meso-scale data – Hourly generation profiles have been defined for all wind/solar plants in our dataset • Result: Wind and solar generation does not vary unless there is local transmission congestion preventing the resources from being used by the system
18
Wind and Solar Profile Examples
• Synchronized hourly profiles (wind & solar) • Planned VG additions based on extensive data research and stakeholder input • Energy is must-take
19
Reference Case Wind Generation
Average Hourly Wind by Month - PC1
16000 14000 12000 10000 8000 6000 4000 2000 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hour
14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 January February March April May June July August September October November December Annual
20
Sample Load/Generation Profile –
35,000
AZNMNV Sub-region
30,000 25,000 20,000 15,000 10,000 5,000 0 7/10/2020 7/11/2020 7/12/2020 7/13/2020 7/14/2020 7/15/2020 7/16/2020 7/17/2020 7/18/2020 7/19/2020 Combustion Turbine Steam - Other Combined Cycle Other Solar Wind Small Hydro RPS Geothermal Biomass RPS Hydro+PS Steam - Coal Nuclear Demand Dump
Sample Load/Generation Profile –
35,000
NWPP Sub-region
30,000 25,000 20,000 15,000 10,000 5,000 0 7/10/2020 7/11/2020 7/12/2020 7/13/2020 7/14/2020 7/15/2020 7/16/2020 7/17/2020 7/18/2020 7/19/2020 Combustion Turbine Steam - Other Combined Cycle Other Solar Wind Small Hydro RPS Geothermal Biomass RPS Hydro+PS Steam - Coal Nuclear Demand Dump 21
10-Year Regional Transmission Plan
22
www.wecc.biz/10yrPlan
What’s in a Plan
Types of Recommendations?
Expected Future – “The road we’re on” • Analysis of assumptions • Is there sufficient transmission capacity?
• Unanswered questions Identification of Alternatives • Alternative procurement options to meet policy directives at less cost 23 Other Insights • Identification of follow-up studies • Suggestions for addressing unanswered questions • Public policy
24
Questions
Bradley Nickell Director of Transmission Planning Western Electricity Coordinating Council 155 North 400 West Salt Lake City, Utah 84103 801.819.7604
All information on the WECC 10-Year Regional Transmission Plan may be found at http://www.wecc.biz/10yrPlan .
Flexibility Reserves
“Additional reserves required to manage the variability and uncertainty associated with variable generation resources like wind and solar” (NREL)
• E3 and NREL developed calculation methodology Reserve based on 10 minute wind and solar profiles • Provides an uncertainty factor extended to hourly analysis • E3 calculated the hourly flexibility reserves for the TEPPC wind and solar profiles 25 Confidential | ©2012 Ventyx, an ABB company | 25
26
Flexibility Reserve Flow Diagram
Historical load, wind and solar data Statistical analysis Equations that predict next period variability based on current values of load, wind and solar Definition of flex reserve sharing areas (e.g. EIM) Hourly analysis data for study or real-time (Load, Wind and Solar) Hourly reserve time series synchronized to load, wind and solar Production Cost Modeling PROMOD, GridView, etc.
Production modeling results analysis Confidential | ©2012 Ventyx, an ABB company | 26
27
Composite Hourly Reserve Requirement
4% of Daily Peak Load Hourly Flexibility Reserve Composite Hourly Reserve Requirement
1-day Confidential | ©2012 Ventyx, an ABB company | 27
Test Results for August 25 - 26
August 25-26 California South Sub-region Total Gen Reserve Contribution Hourly Reserve Requirement 10000 9000 8000 7000 6000 5000 4000 3000 2000 1000 0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 28 Confidential | ©2012 Ventyx, an ABB company | 28
Example of Hourly Reserve Requirement
29
California South - August 25-26 (MW)
{Load is plotted on secondary axis} 4% of Daily Peak Flex Reserve Solar+Wind Hourly Res 9000 8000 7000 6000 5000 4000 3000 2000 1000 0 1 3 5 7 9 Load (Axis 2) 45000 40000 35000 30000 25000 20000 15000 10000 5000 0
30
Long-term Planning Tool
The LTPT is a GIS-based capital expansion planning tool for use in doing long-term transmission planning studies • Optimizes new generation and transmission build out • Incorporates reliability, policy, environmental, and cost considerations Current Status • Integrated testing continues • Last minute data submittals being incorporated into the model • Will begin production studies in June
Information from the LTPT complements results provided by the production cost model
LTPT Process Flow
Scenarios
Criteria Assertions Environmental Considerations Policy Consideration
Proxies
Data Load Generation Transmission
Identify Resources
Optimize Generation Operating Characteristics Capital Costs
Optimize Transmission
Optimize Transmission Alternative Candidates Alternative Candidates
Results
Analytics Identify High Value Projects Measure Impacts Compare Energy Futures Social Considerations Cultural Considerations Federal & State Mandates Capital Costs Geospatial Stakeholder Collaboration Energy Constraints Capacity Constraints Tiered Optimization Capital Costs Grid Constraints Expansion Plan
Public policy along with reliability, technology, and environmental considerations drive the LTPT
31 Screen Alternatives Inform Other Planning Inform Decision Makers
32
LTPT Renewable Resource Hubs
Leveraging the WREZ Hubs
33
Water Availability and Usage
Water Availability Example
Environmental Data
Bringing land-use into planning processes
• Develop and incorporate information on land, wildlife, cultural, historical, archaeological, and water resources into the transmission planning process 34
Data being integrated into the LTPT
35
Detailed Examination of Expansion Alternatives -
“Bending the Lines”
Optimal Corridor Using ROW and Road Alignments Optimal Cross-Country Corridor
RTEP Long-term Planning Scenarios
To Have and Have Not
Widespread economic growth Increasing standards of living Evolutionary changes in technology
Costs Matter
Narrow and slow economic growth Stagnating standards of living Evolutionary changes in technology
The New Frontier
Widespread economic growth Increasing standards of living Paradigm changes in technology
Technology
Renewables to the Rescue
Narrow and slow economic growth Stagnating standards of living Paradigm changes in technology 36
The Long-term Planning Tool will be used to analyze the long-term scenarios